β-Mn2V2O7 (β-MVO)
was recently reported to be a promising candidate for photoelectrochemical
(PEC) water splitting, with a suitable band gap and band edge positions
and reasonable stability and photoactivity in preliminary tests in
alkaline solution. Here, we present an in-depth evaluation of the
PEC performance and stability of phase-pure nanostructured β-Mn2V2O7 films made by calcination of a
spin-cast molecular ink. We show that β-Mn2V2O7 dissolves in pure water, corrodes in aqueous
electrolytes at pH 7 and 9, and converts to amorphous manganese (hydr)oxides
within minutes at pH 13. Our β-Mn2V2O7 films yielded only miniscule photocurrents (∼μA
cm–2) for the oxidation of iodide, sulfite, or water
and the reduction of iodate or water in borate- and phosphate-buffered
electrolytes at pH 7 and 9, the oxidation of [Fe(CN)6]4– or water at pH 13, and the oxidation of bromide in
acetonitrile, regardless of film calcination temperature and time,
film thickness, and illumination geometry. Minimal photoactivity was
observed even in electrolytes in which film degradation was insignificant
over the duration of the PEC tests. Ultrafast transient absorption
spectroscopy shows that the poor photoactivity is likely the result
of fast hole trapping and recombination at the MVO surface that leaves
few free charge carriers beyond the picosecond time scale. Given its
poor charge transport/extraction and chemical stability, native nanostructured
β-Mn2V2O7 is ineffective for
solar water splitting and future research on this material should
focus on the development of superior syntheses and film morphologies,
MVO alloys, heterostructures, and surface coatings to alleviate recombination
and boost operational stability. This work underscores the importance
of careful follow-up studies of materials identified as “hits”
in combinatorial materials discovery campaigns.