Supporting hospital staff to provide compassionate care: Do Schwartz Center Rounds work in English hospitals?

Abstract

SummaryObjective To assess (1) whether the Schwartz Center Rounds ("Rounds"), a multidisciplinary forum which brings together hospital staff to discuss the nonclinical, social and emotional aspects of caring for patients, could transfer from the US to a UK setting; and (2) whether UK Rounds would achieve a similar positive impact on individuals and teams, and hospital culture.Design The results reported are based on 41 qualitative interviews with context provided by additional quantitative research.Setting We introduced Rounds at two pilot sites, both NHS hospitals providing acute care.Participants Over the one-year, ten-Rounds pilot period, Rounds were attended by 1250 staff across the two sites. We conducted qualitative research into the experiences of staff involved in implementing Rounds at the outset and the end of the pilot.Main outcome measures Interviewees' assessment of the effects of Rounds on participants, their relationships with colleagues, and the wider hospital.Results The findings show that in the two pilot trusts, Rounds are perceived by participants as a source of support and that their benefit may translate into benefits for patients and team working; and that Rounds have the potential to effect change in the hospital culture.Conclusion Rounds appear to transfer successfully from the US to the UK, and there is some evidence that they are having a similarly positive impact, but more research is needed.

Introducing compassion into the education of health care professionals; can Schwartz Rounds help?

“…The more serious the illness the stronger are the fears and taboos, and one immediate strategy that staff may employ is to distance themselves [10]. Menzies-Lyth [11] has described how people withdraw, perhaps for their own emotional protection, and hide behind an array of organizational mechanisms that offer protection (be this uniforms, procedures, targets, or language).…”

Increasing emotional support for healthcare workers can rebalance clinical detachment and empathy

“…These 1-hour sessions involve the presentation of a case study and discussion of the emotional issues it raised, followed by time for questions, reflection, and the sharing of similar experiences, led by a trained facilitator. 8 A 2012 qualitative analysis of the rounds in two UK pilot sites suggested that rounds increased respect, understanding, and empathy between staff, 8 a benefit that consultant psychologist Leslie Morrison says is beginning to be shown to 'spill over into a greater sense of compassion and empathy for patients'.…”

Distress in working on dementia wards – A threat to compassionate care: A grounded theory study

“…Goodrich (2012) suggests that organisations could facilitate this by providing staff with opportunities to reflect with trusted colleagues either in the form of case consultations, supervision or informal engagement. Establishing valued shared goals is also crucial and organisations could support employees by actively rewarding compassionate attributes and behaviours.…”