The rates and selectivity of electrochemical CO2 reduction
are known to be strongly influenced by the identity of alkali metal
cations in the medium. However, experimentally, it remains unclear
whether cation effects arise predominantly from coordinative stabilization
of surface intermediates or from changes in the mean-field electrostatic
environment at the interface. Herein, we show that Au- and Ag-catalyzed
CO2 reduction can occur in the presence of weakly coordinating
(poly)tetraalkylammonium cations. Through competition experiments
in which the catalytic activity of Au was monitored as a function
of the ratio of the organic to metal cation, we identify regimes in
which the organic cation exclusively controls CO2 reduction
selectivity and activity. We observe substantial CO production in
this regime, suggesting that CO2 reduction catalysis can
occur in the absence of Lewis acidic cations, and thus, coordinative
interactions between the electrolyte cations and surface-bound intermediates
are not required for CO2 activation. For both Au and Ag,
we find that tetraalkylammonium cations support catalytic activity
for CO2 reduction on par with alkali metal cations but
with distinct cation activity trends between Au and Ag. These findings
support a revision in electrolyte design rules to include water-soluble
organic cation salts as potential supporting electrolytes for CO2 electrolysis.