Synergising decision making and interventions across human health and environment: concepts for designing a model for infectious diseases

Abstract

The impact of environmental factors on human health outcomes is well established. It is therefore not surprising that interventions aimed at improving human health are often environmental-based, such as restoring riparian vegetation for flood mitigation, with a view to reducing associated infectious disease transmission. Yet the risks and benefits of these interventions on the environment itself are rarely measured, or weighed up against potential health gains. One of the challenges with such an evaluation is the requirement for cross-sectoral support from decision makers in both the health and environmental sectors. To facilitate this support, cross-sectoral models are required that simultaneously estimate the impact of proposed environmental interventions on both sectors. Despite their obvious value, a systematic search of the peer-reviewed literature did not identify any model that concurrently models the impact of environmental intervention on both environmental and human infectious disease related outcomes. In this paper, we conceptually explore potential approaches for designing such a model, using leptospirosis as a case study to highlight the various data sources, spatial scales, temporal scales and required system behaviour that would need to be integrated for a cross-sectoral model of this complexity. By comparing these system requirements against the strengths and limitations of individual modelling techniques, we demonstrate the potential benefits of a hybrid-ensemble approach that uses component models from different frameworks. By combining the strengths of the different techniques to tackle this wicked problem, such a modelling approach supports the prioritisation of environmental interventions that optimise the overall benefit by considering impacts on both human health and the environment.

“A variety of green spaces available to all”: knowledge of patient and community needs in natural spaces as understood by allied health professionals

“…Furthermore, there is a delicate balance to be maintained in ensuring that the advocated solutions do not inadvertently exclude others or compromise the environmental integrity of the spaces in question. As highlighted by one participant, the environmental impact of activities in these spaces should also be considered; hence the need for stakeholders to include non-health perspectives, including from ecologists and landscape designers; with modelling of the health and environmental impacts where possible (see Stanhope et al (2022b) for guidance on intersectoral modelling approaches).…”