Aminomethylenephosphonate-based
scale inhibitors (SIs) have been
widely studied and recognized for several decades to mitigate various
oilfield scales. However, most of these compounds afforded several
drawbacks, such as poor biodegradability and intolerance with the
production system. As environmental regulations become more rigid,
new production chemicals must adhere to certain criteria to qualify
for use in the oil and gas industry, particularly in areas with strict
regulations, such as the Norwegian Sea. The low toxicity of fosfomycin
encouraged us to test fosfomycin and related molecules as new aminomethylene-free
phosphonate SIs for calcite and gypsum scales. The tested chemicals
are fosfomycin disodium salt (
SI-1
), fosfomycin trometamol
(
SI-2
), and hydrolysis of fosfomycin called 1,2-dihydroxypropyl
phosphonic acid (
SI-3
). The inhibition efficiency of
all these chemicals was evaluated against calcite and gypsum scales
compared to commercial oilfield scale inhibitor hydroxyphosphonoacetic
acid (
HPAA
) according to the NACE Standard TM0374-2007.
In addition, the calcite scale inhibition efficiency of all aminomethylene-free
phosphonate SIs (
SI-1
to
SI-3
and
HPAA
) was investigated based on the Heidrun oilfield, Norway.
Moreover, we have reported the calcium compatibility of these chemicals
at various concentrations of SIs and calcium ions at 80 °C over
24 h. All new aminomethylene-free phosphonate SIs showed good gypsum
and calcite inhibition performance. It was also found that all tested
chemicals derived from fosfomycin demonstrated excellent compatibility
with calcium ions of up to 1000 ppm throughout the 24 h experiment
period compared to
HPAA
.