On treatment with HS0,F in S02C1F at O", 3-hydroxy-2,2-dimethyl-3-phenylpropionic acid (la) is transformed into 2-phenyl-3-methyl-2-butenoic acid (2a) (isolated yield: 40-44%). Using monolabelled [3-'3C]-la (la*) and doubly labelled [ 1, 3-I3C2]-la (la**), the migration of HOOC (or a mechanistically equivalent group) was proved; a cross experiment established the intramolecular character of the rearrangement. By following the reaction at low temperature in an NMR. spectrometer, the formation of intermediates and side products was demonstrated.In the typical Whitmore 1,2-shift, for instance Wugner-Meerwein, pinacol, benzilic-acid rearrangements, etc., a group is transferred with its bonding electrons to a (more or less completely) electron-deficient centre. Although electron attracting groups would supposedly be disfavoured in such a migration, a significant number of these groups migrate in typical 1,2-shifts to a carbenium-ion-type C-atom, for instance R-CO in Wagner-Meerwein [2], pinacol [3], epoxide [4], and benzilic-acid rearrangements [ 5 ] , ROOC and analogous groups (for a review see [6]) in Wugner-Meerwein [7], pinacol [El, epoxide [9], benzilic-acid [lo], and dienone-phenol rearrangements [ 1 11, R'RNCO-groups in Wagner-Meerwein [ 121 and benzilic-acid rearrangements [ 131, Ar,P (0)-and (RO),P (0)-groups in Wagner-Meerwein [ 141 and epoxide rearrangements [ 151. The (-O,C)-group, less electron attracting, has been shown to migrate in benzilic acid [ 161 and tert.-ketol rearrangements [ 171.In contrast, a migration of a HOOC group has so far not been demonstrated, though it has been supposed to occur in the enzymatic transformation of phenylalanine to tropic acid [ 1 q3).We have demonstrated [20] that EtOOC-and MeOOC-groups are shifted in the Wagner-Meerwein rearrangements of methyl and ethyl 3-hydroxy-2,2-dimethyl-3-phenylpropionate ( l b and lc) into methyl and ethyl 3-methyl-2-phenyl-2-butenoate (2b and 2c) [7]. As a by-product, the free acid 2a had been isolated [20], but it was not established whether hydrolysis had taken place before or after the ') Preliminary communication: [I].
*)
3,Author to whom correspondence should be addressed. The non-enzymatic deamination, however, proceeds via phenyl migration [ 191.