We systematically compare the dispersion and self-assembly of silica nanoparticles (NPs) grafted with either a sparse monomodal long chain length polystyrene (PS) brush or a bimodal brush comprised of a sparse grafting of long PS chains and a dense carpet of short poly(2-vinylpyridine) (P2VP) chains. These two different types of NPs are placed in pure PS matrices of varying molecular weights in a series of experiments. We first show that NP dispersion is generally improved in the case of bimodal brushes. More interestingly, at low PS grafting densities the bimodal brushes give different self-assembled structures relative to the monomodal brushes; we conjecture that the presence of the short P2VP chains in the bimodal brush reduces the effective core−core attractions and thus allows these bidisperse NPs to display self-assembly behavior that is less likely to be kinetically trapped by the strong intercore attractions that control the behavior of monomodal NPs. In this low PS grafting density limit, where we expect the spatial coverage of the brush to be the most nonuniform, we find the formation of "vesicular" structures that are representative of highly asymmetric ("tadpole") surfactants. Our results therefore show that reducing the inter-NP attractions gives rise to a much richer ensemble of NP self-assemblies, apparently with a smaller influence from kinetic traps (or barriers). P olymer nanocomposites (PNCs), mixtures of nanometersized particles and polymer matrices, have attracted continuing interest over the past few decades, primarily because they offer the promise of significant property improvements relative to the pure polymer. 1−6 The mixing of inorganic nanoparticles (NP) with typically hydrophobic polymers, however, is challenging because of their strong energetic dislike for each other. One common strategy to improve their miscibility is to covalently graft the NP surface with polymer chains possessing the same chemistry as the matrix. 7−9 Initially, monomodal 10−12 brushes were used to control particle/ polymer miscibility. Interestingly, in these systems, anisotropic NP morphologies (strings, sheets, or connected structures) were observed when the NPs were sparsely grafted with polymer chains. 11,13,14 This finding was reconciled by the fact that lightly grafted NPs act akin to surfactants, that is, some parts of the particle surface are covered by the grafted chains ("hydrophobic"), while the other hydrophilic parts are exposed to the matrix. 15,16 Very recently bimodal brushes, consisting of a densely grafted, short brush (enthalpic screening for core− core attraction) and a sparsely grafted, long brush (favorable entropic interactions with the matrix chains) have been studied as a route to further improve NP dispersion. 17−21 Again, all the chains were of the same chemistry. These bimodal polymer grafted NPs were found to be well-dispersed across a broad range of matrix molecular weights, a fact that is attributed to the significant reduction in attraction between the particles due to the presen...