Tail Weaponry in Ankylosaurs and Glyptodonts: An Example of a Rare but Strongly Convergent Phenotype

Abstract

The unusual clubbed tails of glyptodonts among mammals and ankylosaurines among dinosaurs most likely functioned as weapons of intraspecific combat or interspecific defense and are characterized by stiffening of the distal tail and, in some taxa, expansion of the distal tail tip. Although similarities in tail weaponry have been noted as a potential example of convergent evolution, this hypothesis has not been tested quantitatively, particularly with metrics that can distinguish convergence from long‐term stasis, assess the relative strength of convergence, and identify potential constraints in the appearance of traits during the stepwise, independent evolution of these structures. Using recently developed metrics of convergence within a phylomorphospace framework, we document that convergence accounts for over 80% of the morphological evolution in traits associated with tail weaponry in ankylosaurs and glyptodonts. In addition, we find that ankylosaurs and glyptodonts shared an independently derived, yet constrained progression of traits correlated with the presence of a tail club, including stiffening of the distal tail as a precedent to expansion of the tail tip in both clades. Despite differences in the anatomical construction of the tail club linked to lineage‐specific historical contingency, these lineages experienced pronounced, quantifiable convergent evolution, supporting hypotheses of functional constraints and shared selective pressures on the evolution of these distinctive weapons. Anat Rec, 303:988–998, 2020. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Dinosaur biodiversity declined well before the asteroid impact, influenced by ecological and environmental pressures

“…Tail clubs are extremely rare across the animal tree of life 114 . The evolution of this structure suggests they experienced an adaptive response to selective pressures imposed by predation (predator deterrence and active defence), which prompted the evolution of skeletal precursors necessary to support the evolution of tail clubs 114 , 115 . Thus we may hypothesize that ankylosaurs may have acted as predator deterrence for the whole herbivorous guild.…”

The early diversification of ray‐finned fishes (Actinopterygii): hypotheses, challenges and future prospects

“…In tandem, investigating survivorship and selectivity through mass extinctions, such as the end‐Devonian, among and between lineages (Soul & Friedman, 2017 ; Allen et al ., 2019 ) may reveal more detail on the effects of mass extinctions (Sallan & Friedman, 2012 ; Sallan & Galimberti, 2015 ). Deep‐bodied Palaeozoic actinopterygians also represent an obvious test case for exploring these techniques, for example by quantifying convergence and teasing this apart from shared history (Speed & Arbuckle, 2017 ; Arbour & Zanno, 2020 ). Previous work has examined shifts between marine and non‐marine habitats in other fossil groups (and coincident changes in morphology and disparity; Lamsdell, 2016 ).…”

Wing Musculature Reconstruction in Extinct Flightless Auks (PinguinusandMancalla) Reveals Incomplete Convergence with Penguins (Spheniscidae) Due to Differing Ancestral States

“…Recent studies have shown that superficially convergent phenotypes do arise via diverse evolutionary pathways and/or developmental mechanisms in different clades ( Ng and Smith 2016 ; Morinaga and Bergmann 2017 ; Bergmann and Morinaga 2019 ; Arbour and Zanno 2020 ). The prevalence of incomplete convergence is now widely appreciated in many different systems, although the detailed underpinnings of incompleteness largely remain to be explored (e.g., Losos 2010 , 2011 ; Kaeuffer et al.…”