Taming Distraction: The Second Screen Assemblage, Television and the Classroom

Abstract

This article argues that television's resilience in the current media landscape can best be understood by analyzing its role in a broader quest to organize attention across different media. For quite a while, the mobile phone was considered to be a disturbance both for watching television and for classroom teaching. In recent years, however, strategies have been developed to turn the second screen's distractive potential into a source for intensified, personalized and social attention. This has consequences for television's position in a multimedia assemblage: television's alleged specificities (e.g. liveness) become mouldable features, which are selectively applied to guide the attention of users across different devices and platforms. Television does not end, but some of its traditional features do only persist because of its strategic complementarity with other media; others are re-adapted by new technologies thereby spreading televisual modes of attention across multiple screens. The article delineates the historical development of simultaneous media use as a 'problematization'-from alternating (and competitive) media use to multitasking and finally complementary use of different media. Additionally, it shows how similar strategies of managing attention are applied in the 'digital classroom'. While deliberately avoiding to pin down, what television is, the analysis of the problem of attention allows for tracing how old and new media features are constantly reshuffled. This article combines three arguments: (1) the second screen is conceived of as both a danger to attention and a tool to manage attention. (2) To organize attention, the second screen assemblage modulates the specific qualities of television and all the other devices involved. (3) While being a fragile and often inconsistent assemblage, the second screen spreads its dynamics-and especially the problem of attention-far beyond television, e.g. into the realm of teaching.

Momentary Motivations for Digital Disconnection: An Experience Sampling Study

“…Repeatedly giving in to digital distractions likely leads to negative consequences, such as avoiding important tasks (e.g., Hong et al, 2021) or shifts in attention (e.g. media multitasking, Stauff, 2016). Additionally, digital technologies are often perceived as intrusive, demanding, or prone to overuse (e.g., Büchi et al, 2019;Halfmann & Rieger, 2019;Schneider et al, 2022).…”

Mapping Design Spaces for Audience Participation in Game Live Streaming

“…Li [49] suggests that viewer attention afects the pacing experience because it is not evenly distributed across live streams; simultaneous use of diferent media scatters attention, and intensifes distraction [75]. In games, there also exists a duality between playtime (the time the player takes to play) and event time (the time taken in the game world) [43].…”

Sporting Community: Activism and Responsibility in Turbulent Times

“…While Nielsen media reports that linear TV still outpaces non-linear streaming engagement for U.S. TV homes, 1 it is clear that the study of and teaching about television must think through the “televisual” as an interconnected web of industry, text, context, and publics across platforms. Television studies scholarship most productively thinks about the “televisual” as “a densely interrelated assemblage of devices and practices” (Stauff 2016, 189) that, based on “technological capabilities . .…”