Objective: We assessed whether clinical and imaging features of subjects with apraxia of speech (AOS) more severe than aphasia (dominant AOS) are more similar to agrammatic primary progressive aphasia (agPPA) or to primary progressive AOS (PPAOS).Methods: Sixty-seven subjects (PPAOS 5 18, dominant AOS 5 10, agPPA 5 9, age-matched controls 5 30) who all had volumetric MRI, diffusion tensor imaging, F18-fluorodeoxyglucose and C11-labeled Pittsburgh compound B (PiB)-PET scanning, as well as neurologic and speech and language assessments, were included in this case-control study. AOS was classified as either type 1, predominated by sound distortions and distorted sound substitutions, or type 2, predominated by syllabically segmented prosodic speech patterns.
Results:The dominant AOS subjects most often had AOS type 2, similar to PPAOS. In contrast, agPPA subjects most often had type 1 (p 5 0.01). Both dominant AOS and PPAOS showed focal imaging abnormalities in premotor cortex, whereas agPPA showed widespread involvement affecting premotor, prefrontal, temporal and parietal lobes, caudate, and insula. Only the dominant AOS and PPAOS groups showed midbrain atrophy compared with controls. No differences were observed in PiB binding across all 3 groups, with the majority being PiB negative.
Conclusion:These results suggest that dominant AOS is more similar to PPAOS than agPPA, with dominant AOS and PPAOS exhibiting a clinically distinguishable subtype of progressive AOS compared with agPPA. Neurology â 2013;81:337-345 GLOSSARY agPPA 5 agrammatic primary progressive aphasia; AOS 5 apraxia of speech; ASRS 5 Apraxia of Speech Rating Scale; DTI 5 diffusion tensor imaging; FA 5 fractional anisotropy; FDG 5 F18-fluorodeoxyglucose; MD 5 mean diffusivity; NOS 5 not otherwise specified; PiB 5 Pittsburgh compound B; PPA 5 primary progressive aphasia; PPAOS 5 primary progressive apraxia of speech; PSPS 5 progressive supranuclear palsy syndrome; TDP-43 5 TAR DNA binding protein of 43 kDa; WAB 5 Western Aphasia Battery.The term apraxia of speech (AOS) is used to denote a motor speech disorder in which abnormalities reflect deficits in the programming of movements for speech production.1,2 Although usually caused by left hemisphere stroke, AOS can also be associated with neurodegenerative disease, and when it is the only sign or symptom, it is labeled primary progressive AOS (PPAOS).3,4 Unlike PPAOS, the term primary progressive aphasia (PPA) is reserved for a neurodegenerative disorder in which the most salient feature is language dysfunction. 5-7 Agrammatic PPA (agPPA) is one subtype of PPA, characterized by specific abnormalities that affect grammar and syntax in verbal or written expression. 8,9 Although it is recognized that many subjects with agPPA may have AOS, the most salient feature of agPPA is aphasia. In fact, to be diagnosed with any variant of PPA, 8 language difficulty must be the most prominent clinical feature at symptom onset and for the initial phases of the disease; deficits cannot be due to "disruption o...