A no-insulation (NI) pancake coil was wound with a 23 m long REBCO tape containing multiple ‘defects’, at which local critical currents are substantially lower (<80%) than the tape’s lengthwise average. During a charging test up to 60 A in a bath of liquid nitrogen at 77 K, the test coil showed ‘defect-irrelevant’ behaviors, i.e. coil terminal voltages and center fields in steady-state operations were barely discernible from those of an ideal ‘defect-free’ coil. Also, the critical current (Ic) of the coil was measured to be 68 A, close to 72 A estimated from the measured Ic angular dependency data of a defect-free sample tape that was used for construction of the coil. The results demonstrate a potential to build a pancake coil with REBCO tapes regardless of their defects, which may lead to a substantial reduction in the construction cost of high field NI REBCO magnets.