Temporary work visas as US-Haiti development cooperation: a preliminary impact evaluation

Abstract

We report a small-sample, preliminary evaluation of the economic impact of temporary overseas work by Haitian agricultural workers. This work occurs in the USA in the context of a pilot program designed as a form of post-disaster development assistance to Haiti. We find that the effects of matching new seasonal agricultural jobs in the USA with Haitian workers differs markedly from the effects of more traditional forms of assistance to Haiti, in three ways: the economic benefits are shared roughly equally between Haiti and the USA; these benefits are very large, including raising the value of Haitian workers' labor by a multiple of 15; and the portion of the benefits accruing to Haiti is uncommonly well targeted for the direct benefit of poor Haitian households. We discuss implementation challenges faced by the program and the potential for policies of this kind to complement more traditional forms of development and humanitarian assistance. JEL Classification: F22, O15, O22, R23

Recognising knowledge transfers in ‘unskilled’ and ‘low‐skilled’ international migration: Insights from Pacific Island seasonal workers in rural Australia

“…These reflections are not only germane for the SWP, but for similar schemes globally, e.g. New Zealand's RSE, Canada's Seasonal Agricultural Worker Programme and a fledgling pilot project enabling Haitian farmers to do temporary agricultural work in the USA (Basok, ; Hennebry and Preibisch, ; Carvajal Gutiérrez and Johnson, ; Clemens and Postel, ). They may also generate new ideas for how temporary labour mobility schemes in the agricultural sector (which are already proving to help build resilience during times of natural disasters, e.g.…”

Deterring Emigration with Foreign Aid: An Overview of Evidence from Low‐Income Countries

“…Instead, aid agencies seeking to shape future migration flows can focus on cooperation with migrant‐origin countries that alters how migration occurs, maximizing its potential benefits for everyone involved. Aid agencies can work with migrant‐origin countries to develop safe, lawful, and mutually beneficial channels for lower‐skill labor mobility (Gibson and McKenzie ; Clemens and Postel ). Foreign assistance is often required for up‐front costs like providing identity documents to potential migrants, developing systems to monitor and enforce labor recruitment laws, and agencies to monitor returns and prevent overstays.…”

Post‐War Recovery and the Role of Markets: Policy Insights from Six Years of Research

“…But from the perspective of people attempting to rebuild their lives after conflict, it would promise immense opportunities for recovery. (It might also, as Clemens and Postel () report, generate substantial economic gains for populations in ‘host’ or ‘receiving’ countries. )…”