“Tense” /æ/ is still lax: A phonotactics study

Abstract

The production of the lax vowel /æ/ is widely studied as a sociolinguistic variable in American English, as several dialects differ in the allophonic distribution of lax and tense variants of the vowel. Using a forced-choice well-formedness judgment task, this paper tests whether the /æ/ used by Northern Cities Shift (NCS) speakers, which is described as a raised and tensed [ɛə] in all environments, is still represented as a lax vowel in speakers’ grammars. Participants who were native speakers of California English, which only tenses preceding nasals, and NCS English, which tenses everywhere, were asked to choose which of a pair of nonce words, constructed to include a lax-only environment /Vsk, Vsp/, as in gasp, risk, sounds more like a possible English word. California English speakers significantly prefer frames containing lax vowels, including [æ], over those containing tense vowels. NCS speakers respond in the same way: they favor [ɛə] in trials like [bɛəsp] vs. [bisp] just as California English speakers favor [æ] in [bæsp] vs. [bisp]. This suggests they keep the vowel in the phonologically active class usually considered to be lax vowels, providing evidence that speakers generalize features based on lexical distributions rather than phonetic properties.

Phonological mergers have systemic phonetic consequences:palm, trees, and the Low Back Merger Shift

“…This is not, however, an indication that TRAP becomes phonologically recategorized as [+Peripheral] in the variety (see also Labov, 1994:505). Perceptual support for this claim comes from Duncan (2016), who tested the acceptability of [Vsk] and [Vsp] nonce words and found that for both California and TRAP-"tensing" Northern Cities Shift participants, TRAP -presented as low and front for California participants and raised and front for Northern Cities Shift participants-were judged equally as acceptable in [Vsk] and [Vsp] nonce words as DRESS and KIT, and, like DRESS and KIT, more acceptable than FACE or FLEECE. Duncan (2016:11) concluded that Northern Cities Shift TRAP is phonologically lax regardless of its phonetic characteristics.…”