“…Tropospheric NO 2 column retrievals from satellites have been evaluated with in situ NO 2 profile measurements from aircraft (Heland et al, 2002;Martin et al, 2006;Boersma et al, 2008a;Bucsela et al, 2008Bucsela et al, , 2013Celarier et al, 2008;Hains et al, 2010), NO 2 column measurements from groundbased and airborne instruments Celarier et al, 2008;Brinksma et al, 2008;Kramer et al, 2008;Irie et al, 2008Irie et al, , 2012Wenig et al, 2008;Oetjen et al, 2013), in situ surface measurements (Schaub et al, 2006;Blond et al, 2007;Boersma et al, 2009;Lamsal et al, 2008Lamsal et al, , 2010, and a bottom-up NO x emission inventory (Lamsal et al, 2010). Aircraft offer precise in situ measurements within vertical spirals covering a spatial domain over a satellite field of view, but these are generally campaign-based experiments spanning only a few days to weeks and are limited by the need to extrapolate below the lowest measurement altitude (e.g.…”