Text Messaging Adherence Intervention for Adolescents and Young Adults with Chronic Kidney Disease: Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial and Stakeholder Interviews

Abstract

Background Up to one-third of adolescents and young adults (11-21 years old) with chronic kidney disease exhibit suboptimal rates of adherence to renal-protective antihypertensive medications. Mobile health interventions may promote higher adherence to these medicines in these individuals, but empirical research is needed to inform best practices for applying these modalities. Objective In this multiphase investigation, we developed and tested a theoretically informed text messaging intervention based on the COM-B model, a well-established health intervention framework stating that capability, opportunity, and motivation interactively modify health behaviors, to improve participants’ antihypertensive medication adherence in a pilot randomized controlled trial. Qualitative data on user experiences were obtained. Methods In phase 1, intervention messages (Reminder+COM-B Message) were developed via stakeholder engagement of participants and pediatric nephrologists. In phase 2, the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention was tested against a Reminder-only Message active control condition in an 8-week pilot randomized controlled trial. The primary outcome was daily electronically monitored antihypertensive medication adherence and secondary outcomes included pre-post participant surveys of adherence self-efficacy, adherence barriers, outcome expectancies for taking medicine, and motivation for and importance of taking medicine. In phase 3, qualitative interviews related to user experiences were conducted with participants in the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention group. Results Following phase 1, 34 participants (mean age 16.59 years, 41% female, 38% African American/Black, 35% hypertension diagnosis) completed the phase 2 pilot randomized controlled trial (n=18 in the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention group, n=16 in the Reminder-only Message active control group). All participants in the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention group completed a phase 3 qualitative interview. Overall, study procedures were feasible and the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention was acceptable to the participants (eg, 15/18 participants reported reading the majority of messages sent to them, 0/18 reported that the messages reduced their desire to take medicine). Prerandomization, there were no significant group differences in the rate of change in daily adherence over time. However, postrandomization, there was a significant group by time interaction (B=.01, P=.04) in which daily adherence decreased significantly over time in the Reminder-only Message active control group but remained stable in the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention group. There were no significant differences between groups in pre-post changes in survey responses. Qualitative interviews revealed participants’ perceptions of how the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention changed adherence behavior and highlighted several areas for improving the intervention (eg, adapt messaging timing, intensity, and content to match daily adherence, send praise when medicine is taken). Conclusions The Reminder+COM-B Message intervention was feasible and acceptable to adolescents/young adults and demonstrated potential to promote participants’ daily medication adherence beyond simple reminders. Further research is needed to determine the Reminder+COM-B Message intervention’s mechanisms of adherence behavior change and to incorporate qualitative participant feedback into a modified version of this intervention to enhance its acceptability. Trial Registration ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03651596; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03651596

Barriers to medication adherence in sickle cell disease: A comprehensive theory‐based evaluation using the COM‐B model

“…Digitally delivered interventions would be able to be tailored to a patient's individual needs and could address multiple BCTs. The development of mHealth intervention apps that allow for several components of the COM‐B model to be targeted have been done in diabetes, hypertension, and chronic kidney disease 55–57 …”

A Smartphone App to Support Adherence to Inhaled Corticosteroids in Young Adults With Asthma: Multi-Methods Feasibility Study

“…This design is consistent with recent feasibility studies of self-management mHealth interventions for young people with a range of chronic conditions [ 59 , 111 - 115 ], including asthma [ 53 ]. Furthermore, recent randomized feasibility studies of such interventions for young people [ 116 , 117 ] and asthma specifically [ 44 , 118 ] have reported no significant difference in retention rates between intervention and control groups. Therefore, the feasibility of randomizing young adults was not considered a key parameter for this initial investigation in which feasibility of recruitment and retention were deemed more pertinent to focus on at this early stage.…”

Digital health technologies to support medication adherence in chronic kidney disease

“… 31 A study of 34 adolescents and young adults with CKD found improvements in electronically monitored adherence with the use of a 8‐week program of education and support text messages ( p = 0.04). 34 There was no significant change in self‐efficacy scores. In the TAKE‐IT randomized trial, 169 adolescents or young adults with kidney transplants received regular text messages, e‐mails and/or visual cue dose reminders, and third monthly face‐to‐face coaching sessions 12 months, resulting in significantly greater odds of taking medications at or near the prescribed time (OR 1.74; 95% CI 1.21–2.50).…”

“…There are few examples of text message programs rigorously assessed in people with CKD or kidney transplants, and these have been limited by small sample size and short duration 31 . A study of 34 adolescents and young adults with CKD found improvements in electronically monitored adherence with the use of a 8‐week program of education and support text messages ( p = 0.04) 34 . There was no significant change in self‐efficacy scores.…”