The 1st Millennium AD Mediterranean Shipbuilding Transition at Dor/Tantura Lagoon, Israel: Dating the Dor 2001/1 Shipwreck

Abstract

During the 1st millennium AD, a fundamental set of changes in ship design, building methods, and sequence of construction took place in the Mediterranean. This process is known as the "Transition in Construction." Before the Transition, ship hull design was based longitudinally on the ship's strakes ("shell-first"). By about the mid-1st millennium AD, the concept and construction of ship hulls had changed and were based on the ship's frames ("frame-based"). The Transition was a complex, nonlinear evolution. High-precision dating of the construction and service period of ships built during the 1st millennium is essential for elucidating the Transition process. Such dating precision is possible using radiocarbon wiggle-matching and Bayesian analysis techniques. The following study uses these techniques to determine the construction, launch, and final voyage (wrecking) dates of Dor 2001/1, a Byzantine shipwreck from northern Israel that was built based on frames. The results indicate that Dor 2001/1 was likely constructed and launched in the first third of the 6th century AD and was wrecked no later than AD 540. This is one of the earliest frame-based ships found in the Mediterranean so far. Dor 2001/1 is therefore an important shipwreck in understanding the Transition, since it provides evidence that frame-based hulls were already being built by the mid-1st millennium AD, about 500 yr earlier than has been commonly accepted.

Delivering the Deep: Maritime archaeology for the 21st century: selected papers from IKUWA 7

“…Current research suggests that they come from a source also utilised for timber repairs to Hagia Sophia and in a Byzantine fort at Capidava in Romania, most likely from the southwestern Black Sea region (Wazny et al 2017: 178-181). 9 See also Lorentzen et al's (2014aLorentzen et al's ( , 2014b 'wiggle-matching' study of the nineteenth-century Akko 1 shipwreck, also built of oak: the ship's estimated service life (under 10 years) is similar to that of Dor 2001/1.…”

A revised radiocarbon calibration curve 350–250 BCE impacts high-precision dating of the Kyrenia Ship

“…However, based on what we know of comparable historical or ethnographic comparisons (e.g. [62] at p.17; [63] at p.142) and from shipwreck sites with dating information available [15,[64][65][66], an average, or even typical maximum, ship service period of 20-30 years might be estimated for antique wooden vessels, although many ships in fact had much shorter service periods. Thus, conservatively, we might limit the period represented in total by the collection of shorter/short-lived sample material from the shipwreck.…”

Multianalytical approach to the exceptional Late Roman shipwreck of Ses Fontanelles (Mallorca, Balearic Islands)

“…Apart from the studies of conservation science, it is worth mentioning the advance in the use of geophysics and in general remote sensing techniques in the detection and monitoring of shipwrecks with spectacular results (e.g., Caratori et al 2006 Ward and Ballard, 2004). Archaeobotany in general has been essential for the study of the wood used in shipbuilding and providing important information on provenance and chronology (e.g., Colombini et al 2003Colombini et al , 2007 Traoré et al 2016;2018) with important contributions from radiocarbon dating (e.g., Lorentzen et al 2014). These approaches have been combined, of course, with the analytical study of the myriad of materials that formed part of the cargoes or of the crew's belongings on board, notably including inorganic materials such ceramics, glass, metals, stones, but also different organic materials and other substances (Colombini et al 2003;Muller 2004;Lempiäinen et al 2022).…”