Using Bronfenbrenner’s bioecological systems theory, this study investigated the school experiences of nine high-ability students from three secondary schools in rural Western India. Analyses of semistructured interviews revealed several interconnected systems of influences on the school experiences of participants. Intrapersonal aspects such as positive academic self-perceptions, constant pursuit for academic excellence, and mixed feelings about being formally identified as gifted directly affected school experiences. In the participants’ immediate environment, school aspects such as teacher–student relationships, teaching methods, and curricular content had the most prominent influence on their school experiences. Interactions between family and the school systems had direct and mixed influences on participants’ school experiences. Besides the adversities of rural education, participants emphasized the unique strengths of rural settings in India including the role of extended families, strong rural attachment, and positive relationships with school, teachers, and community that positively contributed to their school experiences. Implications for rural gifted education in India are discussed.