The phylogenetic position of Methanopyrus kandleri has been difficult to determine because reconstructions of phylogenetic trees based on rRNA sequences have been ambiguous. The most probable trees determined by most algorithms place the genus Methanopyrus at the base of a group that includes the halobacteria and the methanogens and their relatives, although occasionally some algorithms place this genus near the eocytes (the hyperthermophilic, sulfur-metabolizing prokaryotes), suggesting that it may belong to this lineage. In order to resolve the phylogeny of the genus Methanopyrus, we determined the sequence of an informative region of elongation factor 1-alpha that contains an 11-amino-acid insertion in eocytes and eukaryotes which is replaced by a 4-amino-acid insertion in methanogens, halobacteria, and eubacteria. On the basis of the results of our elongation factor 1-alpha gene analysis, we concluded that the genus Methanopyrus diverged from the eocyte branch before the eukaryotic and eocyte lineages separated and therefore is not an eocyte.Methanopyrus kandleri is a rod-shaped, gram-positive, methanogenic bacterium that was isolated from a deep thermal vent in the Gulf of California (16). This organism is the first known hyperthermophilic methanogen that grows at temperatures up to 110°C (16). Although extreme thermophily has been found in three phylogenetically different groups of prokaryotes (the eubacteria, the methanogens and their relatives, and the eocytes [hyperthermophilic, principally sulfur-metabolizing prokaryotes]), members of the genus Pyrodictium are the only other prokaryotes that are known to grow at a temperature of 110°C or above (37, 38). On the basis of the results of a 16s rRNA and protein synthesis elongation factor 1-alpha (EF-la) sequence analysis, the genus Pyrodictium was classified as an eocyte taxon (24,32,33,37); therefore, we wanted to determine whether the genus Methanopyrus is also an eocyte taxon.Methanopyrus kandleri appears to represent a unique lineage within the phylogenetically diverse methanogens (18,30), and, consistent with this, the results of a Jukes-Cantor distance and parsimony analysis of the 16s rRNA sequence of this organism have shown that it is only distantly related to the other methanogens (8). A suggestion that M. kandleri may be related to the eukaryotes resulted from the discovery that a eukaryoticlike topoisomerase I molecule is present in Methanopyrus cellsThe most probable tree determined in our analysis of smallsubunit rRNA sequences in which the Jukes-Cantor (19), Kimura (21) and paralinear distance (27) algorithms were used is shown in Fig. 1; the probabilities of this eocyte tree are 72.5, 60.5, and 63.5%, respectively, and the probabilities of the archaebacterial tree (data not shown) are 20.5, 29.5, and 20.0%, respectively. The most probable location of the genus Methanopyrus on the trees obtained with these three algorithms is at the branch labelled A; branch B is less likely, and branch C is least likely. The trees that have been constructed...