Observers made forced-choice opaque/luminous responses to targets of varying luminance and varying size presented (1) on the wall of a laboratory, (2) as a disk within an annulus, and (3) embedded within a Mondrian array presented within a vision tunnel. Lightness matches were also made for nearby opaque surfaces. The results show that the threshold luminance value at which a target begins to appear self-luminous increases with its size, defined as perceived size, not retinal size. Moregenerally,the larger the target, the more an increase in its luminance induces graynesslblackness into the surround and the less it induces luminosityinto the target, and viceversa. Correspondingto this luminosity/grayness tradeoff, there appears to be an invariant: Across a wide variety of conditions, a target begins to appear luminous when its luminance is about 1.7times that of a surface that would appear white in the same illumination. These results show that the luminosity threshold behaves like a surface lightness valuethe maximum lightness value, in fact-and is subject to the same laws of anchoring (such as the area rule proposed by Li & Gilchrist, 1999)as surface lightness.