The effect of ageing on fMRI: Correction for the confounding effects of vascular reactivity evaluated by joint fMRI and MEG in 335 adults

Abstract

In functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) research one is typically interested in neural activity. However, the blood-oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) signal is a composite of both neural and vascular activity. As factors such as age or medication may alter vascular function, it is essential to account for changes in neurovascular coupling when investigating neurocognitive functioning with fMRI. The resting-state fluctuation amplitude (RSFA) in the fMRI signal (rsfMRI) has been proposed as an index of vascular reactivity. The RSFA compares favourably with other techniques such as breath-hold and hypercapnia, but the latter are more difficult to perform in some populations, such as older adults. The RSFA is therefore a candidate for use in adjusting for age-related changes in vascular reactivity in fMRI studies. The use of RSFA is predicated on its sensitivity to vascular rather than neural factors; however, the extent to which each of these factors contributes to RSFA remains to be characterized. The present work addressed these issues by comparing RSFA (i.e., rsfMRI variability) to proxy measures of (i) cardiovascular function in terms of heart rate (HR) and heart rate variability (HRV) and (ii) neural activity in terms of resting state magnetoencephalography (rsMEG). We derived summary scores of RSFA, a sensorimotor task BOLD activation, cardiovascular function and rsMEG variability for 335 healthy older adults in the population-based Cambridge Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience cohort (Cam-CAN; www.cam-can.com). Mediation analysis revealed that the effects of ageing on RSFA were significantly mediated by vascular factors, but importantly not by the variability in neuronal activity. Furthermore, the converse effects of ageing on the rsMEG variability were not mediated by vascular factors. We then examined the effect of RSFA scaling of task-based BOLD in the sensorimotor task. The scaling analysis revealed that much of the effects of age on task-based activation studies with fMRI do not survive correction for changes in vascular reactivity, and are likely to have been overestimated in previous fMRI studies of ageing. The results from the mediation analysis demonstrate that RSFA is modulated by measures of vascular function and is not driven solely by changes in the variance of neural activity. Based on these findings we propose that the RSFA scaling method is articularly useful in large scale and longitudinal neuroimaging studies of ageing, or with frail participants, where alternative measures of vascular reactivity are impractical.

Neuronal Food Reward Activity in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes With Improved Glycemic Control After Bariatric Surgery

“…Moreover, Duarte et al (49) showed that functional brain activation can be influenced by impaired vascular coupling in patients with diabetes. Thus, we controlled the analyses for the individual vascularity as proposed by Tsvetanov et al (31).…”

“…We implemented the method by Tsvetanov et al (31) by using a scaling of the first-level contrast images by the individual resting state fluctuation amplitude before group analyses. Resting state measurements were analyzed using Data Processing Assistant for Resting-State fMRI running on Statistical Parametric Mapping 8 software (32).…”

Thalamic functional connectivity and its association with behavioral performance in older age

“…However, a recent study revealed that, although older adults did exhibit reduced CBF in comparison with younger adults, the uptake of oxygen, lactate, and glucose did not differ between the two age‐groups, suggesting that reduced CBF in older adults does not affect the brain's ability to uptake nutrients (Fisher et al., 2013). Although, others have reported that regionally specific age differences in physiological fluctuations exist, which may only partly reflect those captured on a global level (Tsvetanov et al., 2015). This means that global regression methods may not always be the most accurate method of physiological correction between age‐groups as any regional differences that deviate from the global pattern may be inadequately corrected for.…”

Building a Science of Individual Differences from fMRI

“…While all these methods were developed with the aim of improving group statistics by reducing inter-subject vascular variance, they should be considered for a valid assessment of neural individual differences (see Figure 3(c) [74]). As with any manipulation of the data, there are potential caveats: calibration and normalization methods may remove individual differences of neural origin, for instance if baseline blood oxygenation were linked to neural activity [62].…”

“…As with any manipulation of the data, there are potential caveats: calibration and normalization methods may remove individual differences of neural origin, for instance if baseline blood oxygenation were linked to neural activity [62]. Before such techniques are routinely applied, more examples of their successful application, ideally vetted by an independent measure of neural function [74], are needed.…”