The influence of three coal tar pitches (CTPs), having softening points at 86, 94, and 103 °C, on the thermal behaviour of a defrosted high-volatile coal during co-carbonization and co-pyrolysis was studied. The following research techniques were used: X-raying of the coked charge, TG/FT-IR, ATR and UV spectroscopies, extraction, SEM, STEM, and XRD. It was determined that CTP additives change the structure of the coal plastic layer, the thickness of its zones, and the ordering degree of the structure of semi-cokes to a different extent and independently from their softening points. The softening points of CTPs do not influence the composition and yield of volatile products emitted from blends with pitch as well as the composition, structural-chemical parameters, and topological structure of material extracted from coal blends. It is suggested that such a lack of existence of any correlation between the softening points of CTPs and the degree of their influence on the thermal behaviour of coal was caused by the presence of the atoms of metals (Fe and Zn) in the CTPs. These atoms change the course of the carbonization of the CTPs themselves and their influence on organic substance of coal in blends with CTPs.