“… 10 − 20 Much effort has been made to improve catalytic performance, through modifying the availability or strength of acid and base sites, geometry and coordination of metal ions, or extent of reduction or through mixing different oxides. 12 , 18 , 21 − 25 The use of different oxides and different reaction conditions, and possibly co-catalysts (e.g., Cu, Pd) 15 , 26 or co-reactants (e.g., H 2 , alcohols), 17 , 26 , 27 complicates a comprehensive understanding of the mechanism of this catalytic reaction and the factors that control its activity and selectivity. Different steps including enolization (C–H bond scission at the α position to the carbonyl group) and C–C coupling have been found to be rate-determining in the literature, with different reaction orders and either the presence or absence of the kinetic isotope effect reported.…”