The effect of workplace incivility on service employee creativity: the mediating role of emotional exhaustion and intrinsic motivation

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to examine how workplace incivility (i.e. coworker and customer incivility) affects service employees’ creativity, specifically the way emotional exhaustion at work decreases their intrinsic motivation, and, in turn, damages service employees’ creativity. The purpose of this study, therefore, is to show the mechanism by which both coworker and customer incivility at work affects service employee creativity. Design/methodology/approach Service employees from a hotel in South Korea were surveyed using a self-administered instrument for data collection. Out of 450 questionnaires, a total of 281 usable questionnaires were obtained after list-wise deletion, for a 62.4 per cent response rate. Structural equation modeling analysis provided support for the hypotheses. Findings The results indicate a serial multiple mediator model in which both coworker and customer incivility increase service employees’ emotional exhaustion, which, in turn, reduces their intrinsic motivation at work and ultimately decreases their creativity. That is, the findings of this study reveal a negative relationship between workplace incivility (i.e. coworker and customer incivility) and service employees’ creativity that is fully and sequentially mediated by the service employees’ emotional exhaustion and intrinsic motivation. Research limitations/implications The use of cross-sectional self-reports potentially raises concerns about common method bias. Caution is recommended in reaching conclusions concerning the causal relationships between the variables, as the current study did not capture causality variation. For instance, it may be that emotional exhaustion from incivility gradually compounds over time, leading to a greater negative impact on service employees. In contrast, employees may develop strategies to cope with uncivil behavior over time, which attenuates the negative effects on service employees as time passes. A longitudinal design might offer an alternative to overcome this limitation in future research. Practical implications Considering the findings about the mediating effect of emotional exhaustion between workplace incivility and employee outcomes (i.e. intrinsic motivation and creativity), firms should consider establishing systematic institutional practices and policies to prevent employees from feeling emotionally exhausted from workplace incivility. Executive and senior management teams would benefit by instituting strict policies and regulations which nurture desirable behaviors among organizational members that protect victims of workplace incivility. Originality/value This study is the first to examine the relationship between workplace incivility and creativity. Moreover, the present study attempts to develop an understanding of the underlying mechanism through which both coworker and customer incivility negatively affect service employees’ creativity.

The Relationships between Leader Creativity Expectations, Intrinsic Motivation, and Creative Performance

“…Amabile, Hennessey, & Tighe, 1994;Amabile & Mueller, 2008;Carmeli, Reiter-Palmon, & Ziv, 2010;Shalley, Zhou, & Oldham, 2004) and some recent empirical evidence (e.g. Hannam & Narayan, 2015;Hur et al, 2016;Muñoz-Pascual, & Galende, 2017) have suggested that intrinsic motivation is a mediating construct between different variables and creative performance. Therefore, we propose the following:…”

Linking Tolerance to Workplace Incivility, Service Innovative, Knowledge Hiding, and Job Search Behavior: The Mediating Role of Employee Cynicism

“…Workplace incivility has been associated with unwanted outcomes such as high burnout, emotional exhaustion, negativity, workplace withdrawal, and intention to sabotage (e.g., Abubakar, Yazdian, et al, 2018;Cortina et al, 2001;Hur, Moon, & Jun, 2016); reduced performance and creativity (Arasli et al, 2018;Rahim & Cosby, 2016). The above said outcomes are distinct variables but shares several similarities with variables like employee cynicism, knowledge hiding behavior, job search behavior, and service innovative behavior.…”

An identification‐based model of workplace incivility and employee creativity: evidence from China

“…For instance, Porath and Erez () found incivility instigated by authority or a third party, or just an imagined incivility can reduce the target employees’ creativity by disrupting their cognitive processes. Within a service management context, Hur, Moon and Jun () found incivility from customers and co‐workers decreases service employees’ creativity through the sequentially mediating role of emotional exhaustion and intrinsic motivation. At team level, Sharifirad () suggested that supervisor incivility negatively affects team creative performance by weakening employees’ intention to share knowledge.…”