The Effects of Top-down/Bottom-up Processing and Field-dependent/Field-independent Cognitive Style on Iranian EFL Learners’ Reading Comprehension

Abstract

Abstract-The present study aimed at exploring the effects of top-down/bottom-up processing and field-dependent/field-independent cognitive style on Iranian EFL learners' reading comprehension. That is, it was attempted to find firstly, whether FI learners would perform better when taught through top-down or bottom-up reading instruction model; secondly, whether FD learners would perform better when taught through top-down or bottom-up reading instruction model. Two intact classes including 40 Iranian freshmen EFL students with the same level of reading proficiency tested through reading section of TOEFL test participated in this study. One class was randomly assigned to top-down reading instruction model and the other to bottom-up approach. The study consisted of three stages. At first stage, Group Embedded Figure Test (GEFT) was administered to determine the distribution of subjects along the spectrum of FD/ FI in each group. Then, the treatment was run and finally, both groups received a reading comprehension posttest. The data were analyzed using two independent samples t-tests. The results revealed that FI learners outperform their FD counterparts in bottom-up group. Moreover, the results showed that FD learners were more successful than FI ones when taught through top-down reading instruction model. In light of these findings, the researchers offered recommendations for further research and for EFL reading educators.Index Terms-field-independent, field-dependent, top-down/bottom-up instructional model, reading comprehension

Social Constructivism-Based Reading Comprehension Teaching Design at Politeknik Negeri Sriwijaya

“…Reading is a cognitive process that consists of a reader, a text, and the interaction between the reader and the text. According to Babashamsi (2013), and Fatemi et al (2014), there are three models of reading process: the bottom-up model, the top-down model, and the interactive model.…”

Reflection on Background Knowledge Implementation Using Top-down Activities

“…A number of studies have been conducted to investigate the implementation of topdown processing in learning different skills, including reading, and their application in EFL classroom. Some studies (Fatemi, Vahedi, & Seyyedrezaie, 2014;Murray, 1980) have explained the significant role of implementing top-down activities in reading comprehension. On the other hand, there is lack of studies that investigate students' reaction and problems which probably take place in the implementation of top down activities.…”

The Effect of Study Island Software on Grades 9-11 State Scores in Literacy

“…Reading comprehension programs include reading comprehension strategies (Dewitz, Jones, & Leahy, 2009). Software reading programs can be used as reading comprehension intervention tools for students to improve reading proficiency (Attaprechakul, 2013;Baleghizadeh & Babanour, 2011;Fatemi et al, 2014;Kuhi & Yavari, 2013;Rosenthal & Ehri, 2011;Zarei et al, 2012). Reading software programs are designed to interact with students (Akinbobola & Afolabi, 2009) by retelling a story to increase reading comprehension (Hedin & Conderman, 2010;McNeil, 2011;Norman, 2012;Pang, 2013) via dialogue with peers and teachers (Maine, 2013) where teachers encourage students to read (Meyer et al, 2011;Murphy & Fink, 2012) and monitor students' progress (Chen, Chen, & Sun, 2010).…”