“…However, the lattice matching mechanism is often questioned recently, since some materials with almost the same lattice to that of ice crystal, such as cuprous bromide (CuBr), barium fluoride (BaF 2 ), do not facilitate ice nucleation [12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20] . Besides, recent experiments and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations show many aspects of substrates, such as proton ordering 21 , charge 22,23 , sign of charge 24 , electric field 25 , hydrophobicity 26,27 , and the morphology of surfaces 9,28 , can profoundly affect ice nucleation together, in cooperation or in competition. It is very hard to give a general picture to describe the mechanism of ice nucleation on these various surfaces.…”