The Epistemological Fog in Realising Learning to Learn in European Curriculum Policies

Abstract

The European Union is concerned about the economic prospects of its member states as they have to compete against newly emerging economies with lower wages and high ambitions. Part of the strategy to deal with this economic shadow is to create a knowledge economy, but in order to achieve this, a shift to a competence-based curriculum model is seen as critical. Since the Lisbon strategy in 2000, policy documents have provided guidelines and tools for member states, but progress has been limited and in several states curriculum reforms which favoured competences have been reversed. This article uses interview data from school students from two projects in England focused on enquiry and learning competence, and analysis which draws on the theories of Bernstein, to illustrate their accounts of the difference between traditional and competence-based models. The data demonstrate the tensions caused by pupils' perceptions of the demands of summative assessment systems, which reflect a very different epistemology from experiential/competence models. The authors conclude that greater pedagogical literacy, attention to professional development, assessment reform and engaging students as partners in curriculum reform are needed.

The risks of standardised school building design: Beyond aligning the parts of a learning environment

“…Yet, if a shift was to occur in policy, then the school infrastructure built through PSBP could yet prove to be an extended example, but at government level, of the wasted investment that French et al (2020) highlight, where school design does not align with intended use. Perhaps more insidiously, the other risk for the UK is that these beliefs persist at national policy level, but are overtaken by societal understandings so that students, teachers and communities emerge out of the 'epistemological fog' (Leat et al, 2012) with a new understanding of school learning, but buildings that do not match.…”

What, where, when and how: Finnish children’s perceptions of learning in preschool

“…This ability is commonly referred to as the skill of learning to learn (e.g. Hotulainen, Vinni-Laakso, & Kupiainen, 2020;Leat, Thomas, & Reid, 2012;Trilling & Fadel, 2009). Learning to learn is not something that children are expected to master by themsleves but is included as an objective in various national curricula (e.g.…”

The problems of ‘competence’ and alternatives from the Scandinavian perspective ofBildung

“…The implementation of competence-based education and assessment in different national contexts, as well as across the EU, also poses a challenge (Antunes, 2012;Hillen, Sturm, & Willbergh, 2011;Leat, Thomas, & Reid, 2012;Méhaut & Winch, 2012;Nieveen, 2012;Papanastasiou, 2012;Scholl, 2012;Seikkula-Leino, 2012;Sivesind, 2013;Sundberg, 2012).…”