The experiences of young offenders (aged 18–21) on protection in an Irish prison: using an interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA)

Abstract

Purpose Young offenders are disproportionately represented in the Irish Prison Service (IPS) and are a population with complex needs and highest risk of re-offending. Subsets of young offenders in IPS are placed on Protection for their own and/or other’s safety. There is limited research regarding the experiences of young offenders, and there is none on the subjective experiences of young offenders on Protection that could be identified. This study aims to address a limitation of a previous study on the experiences of young offenders in an Irish prison (Hughes et al., 2017) by providing insight into experiences of young offenders on Protection in Mountjoy Prison. Design/methodology/approach Using a non-experimental, qualitative, semi-structured interview design, a purposive sampling method was used, and six young offenders participated. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim with potentially identifiable information removed to ensure anonymity. An interpretative phenomenological analysis was applied to interpret the data. Findings Two superordinate themes provided an overview of the young offender’s experiences of Protection in an Irish prison: ‘Social Order on Protection’ and ‘Adjustment on Protection’. Research limitations/implications Even though it is a relatively small sample size, this study contributes to existing literature and considers sentence management and clinical implications. Originality/value This study helps to address a gap in literature by providing insight into the overall experiences of young male offenders (aged 18–21) on Protection in an Irish prison. The findings are in line with most researches, which highlight additional negative consequences of “restrictive prisons regimes” such as Protection. This study provides information to prisons for the development of best practice guidelines and better sentence management and delivery of services to young offenders on Protection.

Immigrant prisoners in Italy. Cultural mediation to reduce social isolation and increase migrant prisoner well-being?

“…For such young detainees, it might also be useful to implement cultural mediation to understand the manifestation of the “request for help,” the “feeling bad.” The decoding of this request, its taking into account by staff in the social and health area must be adequately supported given the young age of prisoners and the risk of recidivism (Hughes et al , 2021).…”

Forensic mental health assessments of juvenile misdemeanor cases involving demoralization (status offenses) and delinquency

“…The selection of an appropriate measure by the court to apply toward the juvenile is supposed to have the function of reducing the rate of relapse into antisocial behaviors (Chesser et al , 2023). There is a negligible number of reports of the effectiveness of correctional or treatment interventions in a group of juveniles remaining in isolation until the age of 21, who may constitute an important source of information on whether resocialization changes in their functioning have occurred (Hughes et al , 2021). It is envisaged, therefore, that the current study results will constitute a starting point to the creation of basic principles derived from empirically based practice in juvenile cases in Polish jurisdictions.…”