The flowering of chrysanthemum (Chrysanthemum morifolium Ramat.), inhibited by long-day lighting, can be reversed with a short period of low supplemental blue light (S-BL). Both flowering and the reactive oxygen species (ROS) scavenging processes are primarily driven by sugars created by photosynthetic carbon assimilation. In addition, the antioxidant ability potentially affects flowering in photoperiod- and/or circadian rhythm-dependent manners. This indicates that there is an interactive relationship among blue (B) light, photosynthetic efficiency, sugar accumulation, and antioxidant ability in flowering regulation. Here, 4 h of 30 μmol·m−2·s−1 photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) S-BL was applied at the end of a 13-h long-day period (LD13 + 4B) at different intervals during 60 days of experimental duration. The five experimental groups were named according to the actual number of days of S-BL and their intervals: applied once every day, “60 days-(LD13 + 4B) (100.0%)”; once every other day, “30 days-(LD13 + 4B) (50.0%)”; once every three days, “15 days-(LD13 + 4B) (25.0%)”; once every five days, “10 days-(LD13 + 4B) (16.7%)”; and once every seven days, “7 days-(LD13 + 4B) (11.7%)”. Two non-S-BL control groups were also included: 60 10-h short days (60 days-SD10) and 13-h long days (60 days-LD13). At the harvest stage, varying degrees of flowering were observed except in “60 days-LD13” and “7 days-(LD13 + 4B) (11.7%)”. The number of flowers increased and the flower buds appeared earlier as the proportion of S-BL days increased in LD13 conditions, although the “60 days-SD10” gave the earliest flowering. The proportion of initial, pivotal, and optimal flowering was 16.7% (“10 days-(LD13 + 4B)”), 50.0% (“30 days-(LD13 + 4B)”), and 100.0% (“60 days-(LD13 + 4B)”), respectively. Meanwhile, a series of physiological parameters such as the production of enzymatic or non-enzymatic antioxidants, chlorophyll content, photosynthetic efficiency, enzyme activities, and carbohydrate accumulation were significantly improved by “30 days-(LD13 + 4B) (50.0%)” as a turning point until the peaks appeared in “60 days-(LD13 + 4B) (100.0%)”, as well as the expression of florigenic or anti-florigenic and some antioxidant-synthetic genes. Furthermore, the results of principal component analysis (PCA) indicated that S-BL days positively regulated flowering, photosynthesis, carbohydrate accumulation, and antioxidant production. In aggregate, the pivotal and optimal proportions of S-BL days to reconcile the relationship among flowering, photosynthetic carbon assimilation, and antioxidant ability were 50.0% and 100.0%, respectively. However, there are still significant gaps to be filled in order to determine the specific involvement of blue light and antioxidant abilities in flowering regulation.