The Good Samaritan's new trouble: A study of the changing moral landscape in contemporary China1

Abstract

Modernization often involves changes in behaviour norms, values, and moral reasoning; China is by no means an exception. The present study focuses on a rare type of extreme immoral cases in which the Good Samaritan is extorted by the very person being helped. A particular effort is made to unpack why most extortionists of the Good Samaritan are elderly people. Despite its rare occurrence, cases of extorting Good Samaritans have seriously negative impacts on social trust, compassion, and the principle of reciprocity. Yet, a close analysis of the cases and public opinions reveals the complexity of the seemingly straight immoral behaviour, especially the tension between two moral systems and the challenge of dealing with strangers, which in turn reflect the changing moral landscape in contemporary Chinese society.

The Moralities of Intellectual Property: Subtitle Groups as Cultural Brokers in China

“…Subtitle groups manage to work through the growing criticism of shanzhai by developing a particular ethos of unselfish devotion paired with diligent participation. While these two values have gradually disappeared among the younger generations in China, so that egoism has become extreme and everyone seeks personal benefit (Yan 2009(Yan , 2012, subtitlers embody these virtues through their actions of translating and disseminating knowledge as volunteers. The spirit of sharing with no thought of profit earns the public's admiration and immunises subtitlers against harsh criticism for intellectual property infringement.…”

Enclave Urbanism In China: Consequences and Interpretations

“…Here the differentiation between in-groups and out-groups has historically structured meetings with others-and meetings are generally organized through existing contacts. Attitudes toward others, including responsibilities and morality, are largely determined by the question of whether others belong to the in-group or not (Yan, 2009). Therefore, it seems far from certain that open encounters in freely accessible public spaces provide a viable solution in the current Chinese context.…”

A New Measure of Interpersonal Exploitativeness

“…Game theorists interested in cooperation routinely speak of exploitation as a common strategy for maximizing one’s own outcomes in an economic exchange. In addition, anthropologists (e.g., Yan, 2009) and criminologists (e.g., Wiebe, 2004), have either explicitly or implicitly attributed various aspects of social harmony and disharmony to the adherence to, or the departure from, the norm of reciprocity.…”