The “Governor’s Residency” at Tel ‘Eton, The United Monarchy, and the Impact of the Old-House Effect on Large-Scale Archaeological Reconstructions

Abstract

ABSTRACT. The "governor's residency" at Tel 'Eton was destroyed in the late 8th century BCE in an Assyrian military campaign. While the numerous finds enable a detailed reconstruction of life on the eve of the destruction, this elite house was cleaned continuously, and since no floor raisings were identified, little was known of the building's period of use. Radiocarbon ( 14 C) samples taken from within a foundation deposit and from the floor make-up, however, indicate that the earliest phase of the residency was built in the late 11th-10th century BCE. This has bearings on the date in which social complexity evolved in Judah, on the debate regarding the historicity of the kingdom of David and Solomon, and it also provides the earliest date for the use of ashlar stones in Judah. Finally, the long life of the "governor's residency" exemplifies a little addressed phenomenon-the old-house effect-in which buildings and settlements existed for a few centuries, but only left significant remains from their last phase. The earlier phases are hardly represented in the finds, barely studied, and rarely published. We suggest that the old-house effect influences archaeological interpretations worldwide, and is also responsible for recent attempts to down-date social complexity in Judah.

Lachish Fortifications and State Formation in the Biblical Kingdom of Judah in Light of Radiometric Datings

“…The fortified city of Level V was built at Lachish to replace Khirbet al-Ra'i, and Socoh and Azekah were built in the Elah Valley to replace Khirbet Qeiyafa (Hasel et al 2017). The recent published radiometric datings from Tel 'Eton fit well into this picture (Faust and Sapir 2018).…”

Challenges and prospects for building radiocarbon chronologies of the earlier Holocene of the Levant

“…Another set of issues, specific to charcoal and building materials, are the old wood and the "old house" effects (Faust and Sapir 2018). Some of the timber species encountered throughout the Levant can be long-lived, so the charcoal produced in burning them provides dates that reflect the growth period of the tree and not the formation of the archaeological context.…”

The Study of the 10th Century BCE in the Early 21st Century CE: An Overview

“…The sophisticated methods of data collection and analysis that resulted from the debate significantly narrowed the chronological gap between the schools, leading most scholars to follow various versions of the traditional, or modified, chronology (e.g., Stager 2003;Mazar 2011;Katz and Faust 2014;Garfinkel et al 2015;2019;Dever 2017;Faust and Sapir 2018;Ortiz 2018;Master 2019), and even Finkelstein raised his chronology dramatically, agreeing that not only the Iron Age IIA, but perhaps even the late Iron Age IIA, started already in the 10th century BCE (e.g., Finkelstein and Piasetzky 2011: 51;Kleiman et al 2019: 534-535). Given the heightened emotions and high stakes, these developments were insufficient to end the dispute, as the minor gap that remained between the schools was sufficient to justify different historical reconstructions; and so the debate goes on.…”