German-Americans: Still Divided by the Reformation 500 Years Later?My first year in Germany-a life-changing experience in many ways-I spent in Münster, in 1975 still a profoundly Catholic city that was the subject of various jokes: "In Münster it's either raining or the bells are ringing; if it's both, it must be Sunday." Or in political parlance, with "Schwarz" or Black signifying Catholic Conservatives: "What is the comparative and superlative of the adjective 'Schwarz'? Schwarz, Münster, Paderborn" (each the seat of a Catholic diocese). As someone of staunch Protestant heritage, a refitted Lutheran theology student no less, it was a bit sobering to walk along the Prinzipalmarkt and see the Lamberti Kirche still sporting the iron cages where the drawn and quartered remains of three radical Anabaptist leaders were hung on the steeple as a warning after their execution when Catholics reconquered the city in 1536. Even as late as my Münster days, one of the Anabaptist rebels provided the name and inspiration for an underground newspaper, Knipperdolling (Münsteraner Generalanzweifler). 1 However, upon further reflection, I realized that Martin Luther was hardly any more sympathetic to these "Ketzer und Schwärmer" of the "left wing of the Reformation." For Catholics, it was an "I told you so" moment; for Lutherans came the sobering realization, similar to what the Confederates experienced when West Virginia seceded from secession and the Free State of Jones tried to, that once you start unraveling an institution, there is no telling where it will stop. Thus we see Protestants splitting into Lutheran and Reformed branches, a breach which took three hundred years to mend, and then only partially. But more importantly for Philadelphia and Pennsylvania, the Reformation resulted in a broad array of "Sektendeutsche" as well: various radical Pietist groupings. It is to them that Germantown and Philadelphia owe their claim as "ground zero" of German America, whose Tricentennial in 1983 was occasion for celebra-