THE HEADLESS HORSEMAN OF CENTRAL INDIA: Sovereignty at Varying Thresholds of Life

Abstract

Building on recent anthropological discussions on sovereignty and life, I examine the political theologies of Thakur baba, a minor sovereign deity in central India. How might we understand spirits and deities as cohabitants with the living? Following Gilles Deleuze, I set out the idea of “varying thresholds of life.” How do we conceptualize relations of power between these thresholds? Engaging Thakur baba's capacity to harm and to bless, I show how this sacred ambivalence may be understood as an expression of deified sovereignty. In contrast to Agamben and Schmitt's more absolutist political theology, I set out a “bipolar” concept of sovereignty as varying relations of force and contract, a tension I find best named by the Vedic mythological pair of Mitra‐Varuna. Rather than a direct mirroring of social or historical sovereignty, I locate Thakur baba's vitality in a weave of kin and spirit relations, and in his status as a human sacrifice. In conclusion I analyze how these deified powers might wax and wane.

The Work of Inscription: Antenatal Care, Birth Documents, and Shan Migrant Women in Chiang Mai

“…Rather than framing the uncertainty and insecurity that Pha's family had gone through as an example of bare life, I focus on the political stakes of giving birth to a non‐citizen and of the gestures made in recognition of this birth. Several anthropological investigations on multiple forms of sovereignty suggest that a theory of bare life can be inadequate to address emerging associations that destabilize the rules of inclusion and exclusion and the particular historical conversion between power and life (Farquhar and Zhang ; Langford ; Singh ). My main focus is not on how one can be violently stripped of her or his own political being at the start of a new human life, but rather how one who starts from the realm of the exception elicits care and slips into the realm of the political.…”

The ethics of efficacy in North India'sgoonda raj(rule of toughs)

“…It is, rather, an act of extraordinary – even incandescent – efficacy which transcends the conventional order of life (and death). There is no better image of relentless doing than a horseman crashing about the battlefield without a head, an image one finds carved into stones all over North Indian countryside (Singh ).…”

On Precariousness and the Ethical Imagination: The Year 2012 in Sociocultural Anthropology

“…If the precarious world is speaking to us in heightened ethical registers, anthropologists were further interested in its proliferating Christian charismatic religious forms. Although a number of articles focus on a variety of religious practices ranging from Islamic (Adely ; Clarke ; Henig ; Mittermaier ) to indigenized Catholic (Tassi ), Siberian Buddhist (Bernstein ; BuckQuijada 2012), and popular Hindu (Singh ), the biggest cluster focuses on evangelical Christianity both far (Chua ; Eriksen ) and near (in the United States and England; see Brahinsky ; Engelke ; Jones ; Luhrman ; McGovern ). Two articles in particular speak to some of the themes raised in this review.…”