The Health Care Experiments at Many Farms: The Navajo, Tuberculosis, and the Limits of Modern Medicine, 1952-1962

Abstract

In January 1952 a team of medical researchers from Cornell Medical College learned that tuberculosis raged untreated on the Navajo Reservation in Arizona. These researchers, led by Walsh McDermott, recognized a valuable opportunity for medical research, and they began a ten-year project to evaluate the efficacy of new antibiotics and test the power of modern medicine to improve the health conditions of an impoverished rural society. The history of this endeavor exposes a series of tensions at the heart of medical research and practice. Researchers exploited the opportunities made possible by the ill-health of a marginalized population, but did so with the cooperation and gratitude of the Navajo. They introduced new antibiotics that liberated patients from hospitals, but erected an intrusive system of outpatient surveillance. They provided innovative health-care services, but failed to reduce the dominant causes of morbidity and mortality. As every act of treatment became an experiment, they risked undermining the trust on which research and clinical care depended.

Natural History of Tuberculosis: Duration and Fatality of Untreated Pulmonary Tuberculosis in HIV Negative Patients: A Systematic Review

“…Four papers were excluded because all or part of the patients were treated with chemotherapy. Most of these papers also did not contain sufficient follow-up time nor details to calculate 5-year survival or duration of disease [10], [110]–[112].…”

Trilingualism in Education in China: Models and Challenges

“…Otherwise, one would risk making the same mistakes as Walsh McDermott and his team committed at the Navajo Reservation of Many Farms in America, when they set out to alleviate the burden of diseases for American Indians and narrow the gap in health between the natives and other groups in 1952-1962(Jones 2002. Otherwise, one would risk making the same mistakes as Walsh McDermott and his team committed at the Navajo Reservation of Many Farms in America, when they set out to alleviate the burden of diseases for American Indians and narrow the gap in health between the natives and other groups in 1952-1962(Jones 2002.…”

When English Meets Chinese in Tibetan Schools: Towards an Understanding of Multilingual Education in Tibet

“…Otherwise, one would risk making the same mistakes as Walsh McDermott and his team committed at the Navajo Reservation of Many Farms in America, where they set out to alleviate the burden of diseases for American Indians and narrow the gap in health between the natives and other groups in 1952-1962(Jones, 2002. With good intention and great faith, the team successfully eradicated tuberculosis of hospitalised Navajo patients by turning every treatment into an experiment and testing the power of post-war medical technologies such as isoniazid, a new antibiotic.…”