The Hund paradox and stabilization of molecular chiral states

Abstract

The ''paradox of optical isomers'' revealed by Hund in 1927 is re-examined taking into account the interaction of a chiral molecule with phonons of optically inactive solids below the Debye temperature ". It has been shown, that in the strong coupling limit, where the dephasing rate is much higher than the energy splitting frequency, the interaction can lead to a complete loss of coherence between mirror-antipodal states of the molecule due to the phonon-induced dephasing. This, in turn, suppresses tunnelling oscillations between them, so that transitions, which are reversible in time for an isolated chiral molecule become irreversible for the same molecule placed in a low-temperature matrix. In order to propose a particular mechanism of such stabilization, contributions of a single-and multi-phonon processes in the dephasing rate have been evaluated. It has been established that only the two-phonon scattering provides the sufficiently strong dephasing in low-temperature solids. Such a two-phonon mechanism is responsible for the stabilization of molecular chiral states as long as the temperature of the medium is lower ", but exceeds a few Kelvin degrees. These findings are discussed in the context of the evolutionary concept known as ''the cold prehistory of life''.

Spectroscopy of proteins at low temperature. Part I: Experiments with molecular ensembles

“…Following Kagan and Maksimov [104,105] (for biophysical applications of their results see also Ref. [106]), one can decompose this rate into two contributions of incoherent (single phonon) and coherent (multi-phonon) channels…”

Galactic distribution of chirality sources of organic molecules

“…A mechanism exists whereby racemization can occur through a stabilization process involving phonons (i.e. vibratory excess) at very low temperatures as is consistent with much of interstellar space [28].…”

A new application of the modal-Hamiltonian interpretation of quantum mechanics: The problem of optical isomerism

“…More recently, Hund's paradox was formulated in a slightly stronger version (Berlin, Burin and Goldanskii 1996): why do chiral molecules have a definite chirality?…”