The impact of climate change on indigenous people – the implications for the cultural, spiritual, economic and legal rights of indigenous people

Abstract

Scientific evidence has established that athropogenic carbon pollution and climate change will have a catastrophic and devastating impact on indigenous people. 1 Sadly, many of humanity's oldest people face the loss of their traditional homelands and the extinction of their people as early as 2050, 2 which represents one of the greatest losses and tragedies to the human family and one of the most serious crimes in human history. The aim of this article is to therefore critically examine the impact of climate change on indigenous people and to assess the legal rights available to those communities to seek redress. Part 1 of the paper shall examine the catastrophic and devastating impact of climate change on indigenous people. Part 2 of the article shall provide a survey of the most recent legal decisions at a national, regional and international level and provide an analysis of the emerging academic commentary in the field. Part 3 of the article shall critically examine the major historical, philosophical and institutional limitations of the Western juridical tradition to protect and uphold the rights of indigenous people. As such, the focus of the paper is strictly on litigation and it does not engage with the vitally important issues of policy, mitigation and adaptation, from which, in any case, indigenous people have been largely excluded. 3 While there have been positive developments in case law, the literature reveals that climate change litigation offers little hope for indigenous people. The article will conclude by arguing that current domestic and international legal systems as presently constructed are incapable of protecting the unique rights of indigenous people and culminates in a call for the establishment of an International Court for Human Rights and an International Court for the Environment to prevent the destruction of the traditional homelands of indigenous people and the extinction of humanity's oldest people.We express our solidarity as Indigenous Peoples living in areas that are the most vulnerable to the impacts and root causes of climate change. We reaffirm the unbreakable and sacred connection between land, air, water, oceans, forests, sea ice, plants, animals and our human communities as the material and spiritual basis for our existence. We are deeply alarmed by the accelerating climate devastation brought about by unsustainable development. We are experiencing profound and disproportionate adverse impacts on our cultures, human and environmental health, human rights, well-being, traditional livelihoods, food systems and food sovereignty, local infrastructure, economic viability, and our very survival as Indigenous Peoples. Mother Earth is no longer in a period of climate change, but in climate crisis. We

Arctic sea ice in transformation: A review of recent observed changes and impacts on biology and human activity

“…Despite the impact of climate change on indigenous people, they are among the groups least likely to have their substantive and procedural rights recognized. As a consequence, indigenous people's rights are challenged both by climate change itself and by the current policy measures to mitigate it [ Williams , ]. A point that continues to be stressed is the involvement of indigenous people in governance issues, which is not only of great importance but also an ethical obligation.…”

Climate injustice, criminalisation of land protection and anti-colonial solidarity: Courtroom ethnography in an age of fossil fuel violence

“…Ethnography in courtroom settings requires engagement over time with diverse temporal, political, legal, ethical and relational concerns ( Walenta, 2020 ). With courts around the world playing diverse roles as theatres of power, notions of courtroom ethnography and critical socio-legal analysis might give rise to any number of points of emphasis in navigating tensions around capitalist interests, environmental justice, Indigenous rights and climate concerns ( Setzer & Vanhala, 2019 ; Williams, 2012 ). In certain contexts, research on climate justice is focusing attention to emerging forms of litigation and related optimism ( Klaudt, 2018 ).…”

Climate change litigation: A review of research on courts and litigants in climate governance

“…Of the 130 articles identified systematically, 99 (76% of the total dataset) focus on Global North jurisdictions (either in an in‐depth analysis or as part of a comparative project), 26 (20% of the total dataset) have an international focus or cover jurisdictions in both North and South. Only five of the identified journal articles have a clear focus on litigation or litigation‐related issues in the Global South (He, ; Humby, ; Nyinevi, ; Ugochukwu, ; Williams, ) (Figure ). Other contributions to the literature on climate litigation in Global South countries can be found in edited books (Lord, Goldberg, Rajamani, & Brunnée, ) and as book chapters (Lin, ), but a first comprehensive study focused on Global South climate litigation is yet to be published.…”