The impact of mass-media campaigns on physical activity: a review of reviews through a policy lens

Abstract

Background This review of reviews aimed to: (1) summarize the evidence from published reviews on the effectiveness of mass-media campaigns to promote physical activity (PA) or PA-related determinants (intermediate psychological and proximal outcomes) and (2) to identify policy-relevant recommendations related to successful PA campaigns. Methods An extensive literature search was performed on 1 March 2021. Reviews that evaluated the impact of campaigns on distal (e.g. PA) and/or proximal outcomes of PA (awareness, knowledge, etc.) and that targeted the general population or subsets were included. Quality of reviews was assessed using the AMSTAR-2 tool. Policy-relevant recommendations were systematically derived and synthesized and formulated as good practice statements. A protocol was registered beforehand (ID: CRD42021249184). Results A total of 1915 studies were identified, of which 22 reviews were included. The most consistent evidence was found for the effectiveness of mass-media campaigns on proximal outcomes, while the evidence for distal outcomes was mixed. Good practice statements were derived: (1) to achieve behaviour change, mass-media is an important component of larger, multilevel and multicomponent strategies; (2) mass-media strategies should be coordinated and aligned at local- and national-level and be sustained, monitored and resourced at these levels and (3) media should be tailored to reduce socioeconomic inequalities. Conclusions Mass-media can play an important role in the promotion of PA. In general, evidence was more inconsistent for effectiveness on distal outcomes than for proximal outcomes. Policy-relevant recommendations include that mass-media strategies should be resourced, coordinated, aligned, sustained, monitored and evaluated on the local and national level.

A Cross-Sectional Study Based on Forty Systematic Reviews of Foods with Function Claims (FFC) in Japan: Quality Assessment Using AMSTAR 2

“…Our findings of the poor methodological quality of SRs in the food field are in line with those from assessments of the methodological quality of SRs that used the AMSTAR 2 tool in other fields, including acupuncture [16,17], dentistry [18], Tai Chi [19,20], surgery [21,22], major depression in adults [23], chronic obstructive pulmonary disease [24], cardiovascular risk [25], physical activity [26], pancreatic cancer [27], chronic heart failure [28], cancerrelated fatigue [29], Alzheimer's disease [30], chronic spinal pain [31], neonatal pain [32], hip fractures [33], and atopic eczema [34]. Although the target patients or participants and interventions in those studies differed between each study, all demonstrated that the majority of SRs included had low methodological quality ("low" or "critically low").…”

A public health perspective on mitigating the global burden of chronic liver disease

“…The third category includes community-level mass media and public education campaigns, which appear to improve PA awareness but have mixed effects on increasing actual PA levels. [41] Lastly, at the individual level, the WHO advocates primary care professional-delivered or prompted PA interventions, which are associated with increased rates of moderate to vigorous PA. [42] Obesity Screening for overweight and obesity in the primary care setting is an important individual-level prevention strategy. If detected, the first step is weight loss counseling for diet and PA behavioral change: ranging from brief clinic encounters to intensive multicomponent behavioral interventions.…”

“…Often based at the workplace or schools, these have demonstrated benefits on PA levels. The third category includes community-level mass media and public education campaigns, which appear to improve PA awareness but have mixed effects on increasing actual PA levels 41 . Lastly, at the individual level, the WHO advocates primary care professional-delivered or prompted PA interventions, which are associated with increased rates of moderate to vigorous PA 42 …”

The Physical Activity Environment Policy Index for monitoring government policies and actions to improve physical activity

“… 24 and where gaps were found, we undertook new reviews of empirical studies 25–28 and an umbrella review. 29 PEN researchers mapped, reviewed and synthesized all policy actions and recommendations from these three methodologies during an extensive inductive and deductive process. This led to the development of the PA-EPI framework.…”