The impact of retirement on health: quasi-experimental methods using administrative data

Abstract

BackgroundIs retirement good or bad for health? Disentangling causality is difficult. Much of the previous quasi-experimental research on the effect of health on retirement used self-reported health and relied upon discontinuities in public retirement incentives across Europe. The current study investigated the effect of retirement on health by exploiting discontinuities in private retirement incentives to test the effect of retirement on health using a quasi-experimental study design.MethodsSecondary data (1997–2009) on a cohort of male manufacturing workers in a United States setting. Health status was determined using claims data from private insurance and Medicare. Analyses used employer-based administrative and claims data and claim data from Medicare.ResultsWidely used selection on observables models overstate the negative impact of retirement due to the endogeneity of the decision to retire. In addition, health status as measured by administrative claims data provide some advantages over the more commonly used survey items. Using an instrument and administrative health records, we find null to positive effects from retirement on all fronts, with a possible exception of increased risk for diabetes.ConclusionsThis study provides evidence that retirement is not detrimental and may be beneficial to health for a sample of manufacturing workers. In addition, it supports previous research indicating that quasi-experimental methodologies are necessary to evaluate the relationship between retirement and health, as any selection on observable model will overstate the negative relationship of retirement on health. Further, it provides a model for how such research could be implemented in countries like the United States that do not have a strong public pension program. Finally, it demonstrates that such research need-not rely upon survey data, which has certain shortcomings and is not always available for homogenous samples.

The influence of old-age retirement on health: Causal evidence from the Finnish register data

“…Results regarding mental health show that the impact of retirement is either positive (Atalay and Barrett 2014, Zhu 2016, Oshio and Kan 2017, Belloni et al 2016 and Mazzonna and Perachhi 2017 [for physically demanding jobs]) or is not significant (Behncke 2012, Coe and Zamarro 2011, Mokyr Horner and Cullen 2016. Heller-Sahlgren (2017) does not find immediate effects, but the long-term consequences are strongly negative.…”

The Effects of Retirement on Health-Related Quality of Life of Retirement-Aged Adults for Four Marital Status Subgroups

“…Second, health behavioral variables are current exercise, current smoker, and current drinker. These demographic and health behavior variables are widely used in public health studies (Meyer, et al, 2014;Hessel, 2016;Horner and Cullen, 2016;Zhu, 2016;Shai, 2018). Third, chronic health conditions are heart attack, coronary heart disease, stroke, asthma, and diabetes.…”

“…As an increase in the average life expectancy over the last decades in the Unites Statesthe life expectancy at birth for males (females) had increased from 71.8 (78.8) years in 1990 to 76.1 (81.1) years in 2016 (National Centers for Health Statistics, 2017), the elderly population has steadily grown and the proportion of an individual's life in retirement has increased (Horner and Cullen, 2016). It leads to a major public health concern about the potential consequences on health which may affect long-term health care expenditure.…”

Designing Solutions for the Retirement System – In Search of Balance between Economy and Health

“…Some professions result in lowering the efficiency of the employee, negatively affect his performance, as well as – if to consider the issue from the perspective of the public social security system – generate additional costs related to the appearance of disability entailing the need for treatment, rehabilitation and benefits aimed at the maintenance of an adequate standard of living of a person (7). …”