Twenty-four
biomass-derived compounds and mixtures, identified
based on their physical properties, which could be blended into fuels
to improve spark ignition engine fuel economy, were assessed for their
economic, technology readiness, and environmental viability. These
bio-blendstocks were modeled to be produced biochemically, thermochemically,
or through hybrid processes. To carry out the assessment, 17 metrics
were developed for which each bio-blendstock was determined to be
favorable, neutral, or unfavorable. Cellulosic ethanol was included
as a reference case. Overall economic and, to some extent, environmental
viability is driven by projected yields for each of these processes.
The metrics used in this analysis methodology highlight the near-term
potential to achieve these targeted yield estimates when considering
data quality and current technical readiness for these conversion
strategies. Key knowledge gaps included the degree of purity needed
for use as a bio-blendstock. Less stringent purification requirements
for fuels could cut processing costs and environmental impacts. Additionally,
more information is needed on the blending behavior of many of these
bio-blendstocks with gasoline to support the technology readiness
evaluation. Overall, the technology to produce many of these blendstocks
from biomass is emerging, and as it matures, these assessments must
be revisited. Importantly, considering economic, environmental, and
technology readiness factors, in addition to physical properties of
blendstocks that could be used to boost engine efficiency and fuel
economy, in the early stages of project research and development can
help spotlight those most likely to be viable in the near term.