The impact of user charges on health outcomes in low-income and middle-income countries: a systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundUser charges are widely used health financing mechanisms in many health systems in low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs) due to insufficient public health spending on health. This study systematically reviews the evidence on the relationship between user charges and health outcomes in LMICs, and explores underlying mechanisms of this relationship.MethodsPublished studies were identified via electronic medical, public health, health services and economics databases from 1990 to September 2017. We included studies that evaluated the impact of user charges on health in LMICs using randomised control trial (RCT) or quasi-experimental (QE) study designs. Study quality was assessed using Cochrane Risk of Bias and Risk of Bias in Non-Randomized Studies—of Intervention for RCT and QE studies, respectively.ResultsWe identified 17 studies from 12 countries (five upper-middle income countries, five lower-middle income countries and two low-income countries) that met our selection criteria. The findings suggested a modest relationship between reduction in user charges and improvements in health outcomes, but this depended on health outcomes measured, the populations studied, study quality and policy settings. The relationship between reduced user charges and improved health outcomes was more evident in studies focusing on children and lower-income populations. Studies examining infectious disease–related outcomes, chronic disease management and nutritional outcomes were too few to draw meaningful conclusions. Improved access to healthcare as a result of reduction in out-of-pocket expenditure was identified as the possible causal pathway for improved health.ConclusionsReduced user charges were associated with improved health outcomes, particularly for lower-income groups and children in LMICs. Accelerating progress towards universal health coverage through prepayment mechanisms such as taxation and insurance can lead to improved health outcomes and reduced health inequalities in LMICs.Trial registration numberCRD 42017054737.

Effect of a free healthcare policy on health services utilisation for non‐malarial febrile illness by children under five years in Burkina Faso: an interrupted time series analysis

“…Free healthcare policies aim at partially remove financial barriers to accessing healthcare services, with the ultimate goal of reducing the overall burden of morbidity and mortality, including decreasing maternal and child mortality burden [1,2]. Since the year 2000, several interventions of total or partial abolition of direct payment for health care have emerged in many African countries including Burkina Faso [3].…”

“…Several advantages related to the implementation of partial or total free health care have been described in the literature [1,2,[5][6][7][8][9]. It allows for financial protection of populations [7] and a reduction in household health expenditure [5,8].…”

Assessing the Pattern of Utilisation and Out of Pocket Expenditure in Public and Private Hospitals in India – Lessons for Universal Health Coverage from the Healthcare Rounds of National Sample Survey 1996 to 2017

“…Cost recovery in public sector was a key component of World Bank's advice for LMICs [106,108]. Studies in India and globally have reported the adverse effects of user fees on access and expenditure of the poor for healthcare [11,42,112,[116][117][118]. User fees could have contributed to the reduction in access to public sector in India.…”

Rural and urban differences in health system performance among older Chinese adults: cross-sectional analysis of a national sample

“…Some strategies have been developed to address these concerns such as the "zero-mark-up" policy for essential drugs to control cost escalation, and billions of government investment in public health services especially in rural areas to improve efficiency of resource allocation [61]. Further extended health reforms that are embodied in Healthy China 2030, a government blueprint, are needed to meet the ongoing health problems such as chronic diseases, an aging population, and rising expectations of health [55,62,63]. The capacity of primary healthcare system needs further strengthened to manage the rising burden of chronic diseases and health expenditures [62].…”