In the 1970s, Birman-Craggs-Johnson (BCJ) (Trans AMS 237: 283-309, 1978; Trans AMS 261(1):423-422, 1980) used Rochlin's invariant for homology 3-spheres to construct a remarkable surjective homomorphism σ : I g,1 → B 3 , where I g,1 is the Torelli group and B 3 is a certain F 2 -vector space of Boolean (square-free) polynomials. By pulling back cohomology classes and evaluating them on abelian cycles, we construct 2g 4 +O(g 3 ) dimensions worth of nontrivial elements of H 2 (I g,1 , F 2 ) which cannot be detected rationally. These classes in fact restrict to nontrivial classes in the cohomology of the subgroup K g,1 <