“…Although hummocky cross-stratification (HCS) is perhaps the least well-understood of the major stratification types, it is widely interpreted as being the deposit of large-scale ripples. It is also routinely linked to powerful oscillatory flows partly as a result of its prevalence in ancient lower shoreface and shallow shelf facies (Harms et al, 1975;Bourgeois, 1980;Howard & Reineck, 1981;Dott & Bourgeois, 1982;Allen, 1985;Allen & Pound, 1985;Duke, 1985Duke, , 1987Swift & Nummedal, 1987;Brenchley, 1989;Winn, 1990;Duke et al, 1991;Myrow, 1992a,b;Brenchley et al, 1993;Cheel & Leckie, 1993;Martel & Gibling, 1994;Ito et al, 2001;Clifton, 2006;Yang et al, 2006;Millson et al, 2008;Keumsuk et al, 2009). As this paper highlights, however, there are actually many difficulties with linking normal isotropic HCS to a large-scale ripple origin and, while it may normally be the case that HCS generation requires the presence of oscillatory flows, HCS-like structures occasionally have been recorded from deep-water turbidite sandstone beds (Prave & Duke, 1990;Mulder et al, 2009) and even fluvial deposits (Cotter & Graham, 1991).…”