The Labour Market Characteristics and Labour Market Impacts of Immigrants in Ireland

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is twofold. We first produce a labour market profile of non-Irish immigrants who arrived in Ireland in the ten years to 2003. We then go on to use the labour market profile in estimating the impact of immigration (non-Irish) on the Irish labour market. Immigrants are shown to be a highly educated group. However, they are not all employed in occupations that fully reflect their education levels. The model of the labour market that we use to simulate the impact of immigration differentiates between low-skilled and high-skilled labour. This allows us to estimate the impact of immigrants (a) if they were employed at a level fitting their education and (b) if they were employed in occupations below their educational level. Our results show that under scenario (a) immigrants who arrived between 1993 and 2003 increased GNP by between 3.5 and 3.7 per cent, largely by lowering skilled wages by around 6 per cent and increasing Ireland's competitiveness. Under scenario (b), the increase in GNP is reduced to 3 per cent because the impact on skilled wages is lower. If we assume that immigration is primarily unskilled, the impact on earnings inequality found under (a) and (b) is reversed.

Replacement migration on the edge of the European Union: Wasting human capital?

“…. This is not surprising, given that migrants in many locations work significantly below their potential (Barrett et al, 2006; Bruquetas‐Callejo et al, 2008; Ciupijus, 2011; Drinkwater et al, 2009; Eaton, 1999; Johns, 2013; Schuster et al, 2013).…”

“…This means that human capital is wasted; were it otherwise, higher levels of education should positively correlate with the chances of finding a job in the profession in the destination 3. . This is not surprising, given that migrants in many locations work significantly below their potential (Barrett et al, 2006;Bruquetas-Callejo et al, 2008;Ciupijus, 2011;Drinkwater et al, 2009;Eaton, 1999;Johns, 2013;Schuster et al, 2013).…”

African migrants and stress coping strategies in Australia: Implications for social work

“…Consequently, many migrants face unemployment (Schweitzer et al, 2006) or take up jobs that are lower than the positions they once held in the homeland (Hack-Polay, 2019). Sectors such as hospitality and retail absorb significant numbers of migrants, but they equally largely offer jobs that represent underemployment when compared with the skills that migrants harbour (Barrett et al, 2006; Hack-Polay and Igwe, 2019; Hack-Polay and Mendy, 2017). The lowering of their professional status is a key stressor and source of dislocation in the host country and can be viewed as a significant barrier for migrants in integrating into civil society.…”

Do Attitudes to Immigrants Change in Hard Times? Ireland in a European Context

“…Fourthly, there appears to be no evidence that the wages of Irish nationals have been depressed. The influx of immigrants has more likely acted to dampen down wage rates for immigrant workers in the low-skill service sectors of the economy (see Barrett et al, 2006). Thus, in the context of a positive economic environment, the broadly complementary nature of immigrant workers attitudes to immigration is likely to have either remained stable or became more positive between the 2002 and 2006 surveys.…”