The Maturity Assessment of e-Government in Bandung District Area

Does the Government Effectively in Optimizing Open Data? Analysis "Jago Data" in Yogyakarta Municipality

“…Empirically, practices of Open Government Data in Indonesia and several countries outside there are still found many that are not optimal such as; the lack of involvement of government human resources in the implementation of Open Data (Tryanti, 2019), the speed of adoption of Open Data is still relatively slow (Folmer et al, 2019) and quality of published data is very low (Oliveira et al, 2016), there is a gap between portal transparency and OGD implementation (Corrêa et al, 2014). Moreover, uncertainty of Open Data frameworks within the government (Soegiono, 2018), the lack of Open Government Data harmonization and far from quality standards (Martín et al, 2015), there are several government web portal that only reaches a low level of maturity (Rizana et al, 2019), lack of optimal administration systems and lack of staff expertise in OGD implementation (Zhao & Fan, 2018), the government participation and support which are still relatively small (Soegiono, 2018), and there is no single model for responding to the way to classify information (Sáez Martín et al, 2015), however, as a matter of fact, it can be drawn a whole line that no government has implemented an OGD that can really contribute directly (Pin-Yu & Hsien-Lee, 2018).…”

“…Measured by the intensity of a policy, the provision, variations of data formats, services and data modeling and competition of ideas generated (Chatfield & Reddick, 2017) Portal transparency and OGD harmonization and quality standards (Corrêa et al, 2014;Sáez Martín et al, 2015) Speed of adoption of Open Data implementers (Folmer et al, 2019) Maturity level and can serve the community, government business services, planning transparency, and budget transparency (Prahono & Elidjen, 2015;Rizana et al, 2019) Community participation and government support in the implementation of OGD i.e. budget (Maizunati, 2018;Safaria et al, 2019;Soegiono, 2018) 3…”

“…In addition, referring to the maturity level of adoption of a web portal, the 'opendata.jogjakota.go.id' web portal is at level 1, at this stage, the Jogja Go Open Data (JAGO DATA) portal only provides information in the form of data series to the public in real-time especially for market retribution data, besides human population data, regional taxes data, and government staffing data are updated at the end of each month, based on the maturity level of the model, if reported with the results of research (Prahono & Elidjen, 2015;Rizana et al, 2019) stated that the level of maturity of a portal web is very important in serving the community, government business services, transparency of planning and budget transparency. However, the Jogja Go Open Data website portal only displays data without two-way communication services, in other words that this portal only provides data and information transparently to the public without question-and-answer columns.…”

“…However, empirically, it turns out that OGD is often found in several public sectors, but there are still governments that have not optimized its innovation (Aritonang, 2017;Jayanti, 2018;Pin-Yu & Hsien-Lee, 2018;Safaria, Muhtar, & Irawati, 2019) such as; the lack of involvement of government human resources in implement of Open Data (Tryanti, 2019), speed of adoption of Open Data is still relatively slow (Folmer et al, 2019), timeliness and quality of data published is very low (Oliveira, De Oliveira, Oliveira, & Lóscio, 2016), the lack of harmonization in Open Data implement and its far from quality standards (Martín, Rosario, & Pérez, 2015), the government portal web that only reaches a low level of maturity to shares the data (Rizana, Muhammad, Hediyanto, & Andrawina, 2019), as well as, the lack of optimal administration systems and its expertise of government staff in implement of OGD (Zhao & Fan, 2018). Therefore, there is no public sector that implements Open Government Data which is can really contribute directly and precisely (Pin-Yu & Hsien-Lee, 2018), in addition, it causes a lack of disclosure to the public regarding data and information (Zhenbin, Kankanhalli, Ha, & Tayi, 2019).…”