The Mesh of Civilizations in the Global Network of Digital Communication

Abstract

Conflicts fueled by popular religious mobilization have rekindled the controversy surrounding Samuel Huntington’s theory of changing international alignments in the Post-Cold War era. In The Clash of Civilizations, Huntington challenged Fukuyama’s “end of history” thesis that liberal democracy had emerged victorious out of Post-war ideological and economic rivalries. Based on a top-down analysis of the alignments of nation states, Huntington famously concluded that the axes of international geo-political conflicts had reverted to the ancient cultural divisions that had characterized most of human history. Until recently, however, the debate has had to rely more on polemics than empirical evidence. Moreover, Huntington made this prediction in 1993, before social media connected the world’s population. Do digital communications attenuate or echo the cultural, religious, and ethnic “fault lines” posited by Huntington prior to the global diffusion of social media? We revisit Huntington's thesis using hundreds of millions of anonymized email and Twitter communications among tens of millions of worldwide users to map the global alignment of interpersonal relations. Contrary to the supposedly borderless world of cyberspace, a bottom-up analysis confirms the persistence of the eight culturally differentiated civilizations posited by Huntington, with the divisions corresponding to differences in language, religion, economic development, and spatial distance.

Mapping bilateral information interests using the activity of Wikipedia editors

“…Similar results were found in other studies that analysed Twitter and email communication worldwide (State et al, 2015).…”

Cultural values and cross-cultural video consumption on YouTube

“…Online social media facilitate global access to cultural products, yet this technological capability does not result in cultural convergence [5,6,47]. Instead, consumption of popular videos in culturally different countries appears to be constrained by cultural values.…”

Competition between global and local online social networks

“…We use passenger air travel data as a proxy for the abundance of such ties. This choice is justified by the strong correlation between air travel flows and further measures of inter-country exchange, for instance email communication 22 or Twitter activity 23 .…”