Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics (PCCP) is a high quality journal with a large international readership from many communitiesOnly very important, insightful and high-quality work should be recommended for publication in PCCP.To be accepted in PCCP -a manuscript must report: Very high quality, reproducible new work Important new physical insights of significant general interest A novel, stand-alone contribution Routine or incremental work should not be recommended for publication. Purely synthetic work is not suitable for PCCPIf you rate the article as 'routine' yet recommend acceptance, please give specific reasons in your report.Less than 50% of articles sent for peer review are recommended for publication in PCCP. The current PCCP Impact Factor is 4.20.PCCP is proud to be a leading journal. We thank you very much for your help in evaluating this manuscript. Your advice as a referee is greatly appreciated.With our best wishes, Anna Simpson (pccp@rsc.org) Prof Daniella Goldfarb Managing Editor, PCCP Chair, PCCP Editorial Board
General Guidance (For further details, see the RSC's Refereeing Procedure and Policy)Referees have the responsibility to treat the manuscript as confidential. Please be aware of our Ethical Guidelines which contain full information on the responsibilities of referees and authors.
When preparing your report, please:• Comment on the originality, importance, impact and scientific reliability of the work;• State clearly whether you would like to see the paper accepted or rejected and give detailed comments (with references) that will both help the Editor to make a decision on the paper and the authors to improve it;
Please inform the Editor if:• There is a conflict of interest;• There is a significant part of the work which you cannot referee with confidence;• If the work, or a significant part of the work, has previously been published, including online publication, or if the work represents part of an unduly fragmented investigation.
When submitting your report, please:• Provide your report rapidly and within the specified deadline, or inform the Editor immediately if you cannot do so. We welcome suggestions of alternative referees. The Stern-Gerlach experiment is a seminal experiment in quantum physics, involving the interaction between a particle with spin and an applied magnetic field gradient. A recent article [Wennerström et al., Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2012, 14, 1677-1684 claimed that a full understanding of the Stern-Gerlach experiment can only be attained if transverse spin relaxation is taken into account, generated by fluctuating magnetic fields originating in the magnetic materials which generate the field gradient. This interpretation is contrary to the standard quantum description of the Stern-Gerlach experiment, which requires no dissipative effects. We present simulations of conventional quantum dynamics in the Stern-Gerlach experiment, using extended Wigner functions to describe the propagation of the quantum state in space and time. No relaxation effects are require...