The nexus between gender, collective action for public goods and agriculture: evidence from Malawi

Abstract

Across the developing world, public goods exert significant impacts on the local rural economy in general and agricultural productivity and welfare outcomes in particular. Economic and social-cultural heterogeneity have, however, long been documented as detrimental to collective capacity to provide public goods. In particular, women are often underrepresented in local leadership and decision-making processes, as are young adults and minority ethnic groups. While democratic principles dictate that broad civic engagement by women and other groups could improve the efficiency and effectiveness of local governance and increase public goods provision, the empirical evidence on these hypotheses is scant. This article develops a theoretical model highlighting the complexity of constructing a "fair" schedule of individual contributions, given heterogeneity in costs and benefits that accrue to people depending, for instance, on their gender, age, ethnicity, and education. The model demonstrates that representative leadership and broad participation in community organizations can mitigate the negative impacts of heterogeneity on collective capacity to provide public goods. Nationally representative household survey data from Malawi, combined with geospatial and administrative information, are used to test this hypothesis and to estimate the relationship between collective capacity for public good provision and community median estimates of maize yields and household consumption expenditures per capita. The analysis shows that similarities between the leadership and the general population in terms of gender and age, and active participation by women and young adult in community groups, alleviate the negative effects of heterogeneity and increase collective capacity, which in turn improves agriculture productivity and welfare.JEL classifications: C26, D71, H41, O13, Q12

The impact of distance on parochial altruism: An experimental investigation

“…Let us return to the substantive interpretation of our results. A long-standing finding concerning individual behavior in human societies is that homogeneity within a group facilitates collective action (Hardin 1982;Lichbach 1995;Alesina et al, 1999;Costa and Kahn, 2003b;Centola 2013;Kölle 2015;McCarthy and Kilic 2015;Baldassarri and Abascal, 2020;Mantilla et al, 2021;Drouvelis et al, 2021;Koch et al 2021). Our results indicate a potential additional pathway that may influence individuals to take action based on group identity.…”

Social Capital Typologies and Sustainable Development: Spatial Patterns in the Central and Southern Regions of Malawi

“…An explanation of why the positive association between linking SCI and drought is not significant in areas most effected by drought requires further research to understand the findings. Previous research in Malawi found bridging social capital was positively associated with favourable growing conditions [111] and may explain why lower maximum temperatures are associated with a higher bridging SCI in the east coast and northern area of the Central Region. These areas have lower temperatures compared to the rest of the study area, so conditions are more favourable.…”

Responsibility-driven collective action in the context of rapid rural depopulation

“…Part of the problem is that rural environmental management is a type of regional public good (Mccarthy and Kilic, 2015) that involves a multitude of stakeholders as well as the distribution of benefits and responsibilities among them. In China, in the context of rapid urbanization and rural depopulation, the mechanisms for the maintenance of such village level public goods has collapsed leaving a situation where stakeholders fight for benefits as well as seeking to escape their responsibilities, leading to the failure of effective environmental management.…”