“…Researchers have commonly observed lower species richness in urban areas relative to that of the surrounding rural landscapes (Clergeau, Croci, Jokim€ aki, Kaisanlahti-Jokim€ aki, & Dinetti, 2006;Sandstr€ om, Angelstam, & Mikusinski, 2006). However, these patterns are by no means universal, and other studies have found a non-linear response, in which areas with intermediate levels of urbanization exhibit the highest richness (Blair, 1996;Marzluff, 2001;McKinney, 2002;Tratalos et al, 2007), whilst overall bird abundance often increases from rural to urban areas (Chace & Walsh, 2006;Faeth, Bang, & Saari, 2011;Njorge, NdaNg'ang'a, & Natuhara, 2014) although other studies have found no trend (Chamberlain, Kibuule, Skeen, & Pomeroy, 2017) or inconsistent responses across different cities (Garaffa, Filloy, & Bellocq, 2009;Jokim€ aki, Clergeau, & Kaisanlahti-Jokim€ aki, 2002).…”