“…In this study, no MV"1"• was formed at any pH in the absence of EDTA; it should be noted that the photosensitized formation of MV"1"• in highly alkaline solution in the absence of EDTA has been reported. 19,33 The competition between reactions 3 and 4 for the removal of Ru(bpy)33+ lies at the core of the generation of MV"1"•, There appears to be no controversy over the nature of reaction 3; the value of k¡ has been well established3,34 to be (2.6 ± 0.2) X 109 M'1 s'1, independent of pH. However, published values of fc4, and reports of the behavior of the system relative to the competition between reactions 3 and 4, show very large variations even for experiments performed under very similar conditions at the same pH.…”