The Political Economy of Death in the Age of Information: A Critical Approach to the Digital Afterlife Industry

Abstract

Online technologies enable vast amounts of data to outlive their producers online, thereby giving rise to a new, digital form of afterlife presence. Although researchers have begun investigating the nature of such presence, academic literature has until now failed to acknowledge the role of commercial interests in shaping it. The goal of this paper is to analyse what those interests are and what ethical consequences they may have. This goal is pursued in three steps. First, we introduce the concept of the Digital Afterlife Industry (DAI), and define it as an object of study. Second, we identify the politico-economic interests of the DAI. For this purpose, we develop an analytical approach based on an informational interpretation of Marxian economics. Third, we explain the practical manifestations of the interests using four real life cases. The findings expose the incentives of the DAI to alter what is referred to as the ''informational bodies'' of the dead, which in turn is to be seen as a violation of the principle of human dignity. To prevent such consequences, we argue that the ethical conventions that guide trade with remains of organic bodies may serve as a good model for future regulation of DAI.

Futures of digital death: Past, present and charting emerging research agenda

“…This shift resonates with the emerging interest in HCI research from technology-centric design to infrastructure-centric design (Jack, Chen, & Jackson, 2017;Khairuddin, Sas, & Speed, 2019;Zhang, Sas, Lambert, & Ahmad, 2019). € Ohman and Floridi (2017) coined the term digital after-life industry which they defined as "activity of production of commercial goods or services that involves online usage of digital remains" (p. 644) emphasizing the specific commercial interests underpinning it. Future research on digital remains would benefit from taking such a broader socioeconomic perspective to better contextualize the development of technological solutions and services.…”

AI Case Studies: Potential for Human Health, Space Exploration and Colonisation and a Proposed Superimposition of the Kubler-Ross Change Curve on the Hype Cycle

“…With the help of Pete Trainor from the company Us ai, they were able to develop a chatbot named Bo who was able to replicate aspects of James' thoughts from many conversation James had in 'training' the bot [73]. This is one of several landmark cases which show the potential of the DAI but also seek to call for regulation so that the wishes of both those physically dead and alive are respected and that those who wish to 'live' in a virtual world are accorded the appropriate level of protection and privacy [74], [75].…”

Prayer-Bots and Religious Worship on Twitter: A Call for a Wider Research Agenda

“…This means that the huge presence of the Islamic Twitter supplications will likely continue to grow long after the account holders have died. An array of similar applications, albeit with a secular framing of "immortalizing one's social media presence", have been launched mainly targeting secular Western audiences (Öhman and Floridi 2017). However, such a project of social media immortalization still remains fringe in comparison to the Islamic Prayer Apps.…”