Defects in topologically ordered models have interesting properties that are reminiscent of the anyonic excitations of the models themselves. For example, dislocations in the toric code model are known as twists and possess properties that are analogous to Ising anyons. We strengthen this analogy by using the topological entanglement entropy as a diagnostic tool to identify properties of both defects and excitations in the toric code. Specifically, we show, through explicit calculation, that the toric code model including twists and dyon excitations has the same quantum dimensions, the same total quantum dimension, and the same fusion rules as an Ising anyon model.A fascinating class of many-body quantum systems are those that exhibit topological order [1]. Such systems are characterized by a gapped ground state manifold, with a degeneracy that depends on the boundary conditions, and have anyonic quasi-particle excitations. The degeneracy is robust to local perturbations, and therefore such systems are promising candidates for storing and manipulating quantum information [2][3][4][5].The structure of topologically-ordered systems can be further enriched by the use of domain walls or defects, across which quasi-particles transform nontrivially. We will be most interested in studying these defects in explicit lattice models [6][7][8][9][10], and in particular the model introduced by Bombin [6]. Essentially the same defects have also been studied in Chern-Simons theories [11][12][13]. In both of these settings, it has been shown that such defects can be viewed as having anyonic-like properties that are not associated with the underlying model [6,9,[11][12][13]. More specifically, in a particular two-dimensional topologically ordered spin lattice model known as the toric code, such a lattice dislocation leads to interesting behaviour: the points where dislocations terminate, known as twists, interact with the anyons of the toric code to reproduce properties, such as fusion rules, of nonabelian (specifically, Ising) anyons [6]. This is particularly surprising, as all excitations of the toric code are abelian anyons.In this paper, we further interrogate the analogy between twists and Ising anyons by using topological entanglement entropy (TEE) [14,15] as a diagnostic. Specifically, for a toric code model containing twists, we use the TEE to determine: (i) the total quantum dimension of the lattice with twists; (ii) the quantum dimensions of the objects (quasi-particles and defects) on the lattice, and (iii) the quantum dimensions of all of their fusion products, allowing us to reconstruct the fusion rules for twists and excitations. Our results coincide precisely with those of the Ising anyon model, lending further support to the analogy between the latter and the toric code with twists. We note that TEE is a particularly useful quantity in the context of the toric code, as both the parent Hamiltonian and the modified one with twists are described within the stabilizer formalism and so allow the TEE to be calculated e...